Nilabati Behera v. State of Orissa (1993)

Supreme Court of India · (1993) 2 SCC 746 · 3-Judge Bench

Summary

In a custodial death case, the Court awarded compensation under Article 32 and clarified that public law compensation for violation of fundamental rights is distinct from private tort damages, reinforcing the constitutional tort doctrine.

Facts

  • A young man died in police custody; his mother petitioned the Supreme Court for justice and compensation.
  • The State’s responsibility for custodial death and the nature of monetary relief under public law were in issue.

Issues

  • Whether the Supreme Court can award compensation for violation of Article 21 in public law.
  • How public-law compensation relates to private law tort claims.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Public law compensation

The Court held that monetary compensation can be awarded under Article 32/226 as a public-law remedy for established violation of fundamental rights, especially custodial violence.

Distinct from private tort

Such compensation does not displace the right to sue in tort; it is an additional constitutional response to State wrongdoing.

Decision

Compensation was awarded to the petitioner. Nilabati Behera is a leading authority on constitutional tort and custodial death remedies.

Ratio decidendi

Where the State violates fundamental rights, constitutional courts may grant compensatory relief in public law as an incident of enforcement under Articles 32 and 226.

Exam points

  • Constitutional tort / public-law compensation.
  • Custodial death → Article 21 violation.
  • Distinct from private law damages.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Article 21, Compensation, Custodial Death

All judgments