People's Union for Democratic Rights v. Union of India (1982)

Supreme Court of India · (1982) 3 SCC 235 · 3-Judge Bench

Summary

In the Asiad workers case, the Court held that non-payment of minimum wages amounts to forced labour under Article 23, expanded PIL standing for organisations, and directed enforcement of labour welfare statutes for contract workers on public projects.

Facts

  • Workers employed on Asiad construction projects were alleged to be denied minimum wages and statutory benefits through contractors.
  • PUDR approached the Court by letter petition treated as a writ.

Issues

  • Whether payment below minimum wage constitutes forced labour under Article 23.
  • Whether an organisation has standing to enforce labour rights of workers.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Forced labour expanded

The Court held that labour extracted for less than the minimum wage is forced labour within Article 23, because economic compulsion negates free consent.

PIL standing

Public-spirited organisations may move the Court on behalf of exploited workers who cannot approach the Court themselves.

Decision

Directions for enforcement of labour laws were issued. PUDR is foundational for Article 23 and labour PIL.

Ratio decidendi

Article 23 reaches not only physical compulsion but also economic compulsion that extracts labour below the statutory minimum wage.

Exam points

  • Minimum wage denial = forced labour (Art. 23).
  • Asiad workers PIL.
  • Expanded standing for labour rights.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Labour, Article 23, PIL

All judgments