Justice K.S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) v. Union of India (Aadhaar) (2018)
Supreme Court of India · (2019) 1 SCC 1 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench
Summary
A Constitution Bench largely upheld the Aadhaar framework for targeted delivery of welfare benefits as a proportionate measure, while striking down or reading down certain provisions (including unrestricted private use and some power to store metadata). The privacy judgment of 2017 supplied the doctrinal foundation.
Facts
- After privacy was declared a fundamental right in 2017, challenges to the Aadhaar Act and related notifications were heard on proportionality, surveillance, exclusion, and Money Bill procedure.
Issues
- Whether the Aadhaar scheme violates the fundamental right to privacy.
- Whether mandatory Aadhaar linkage for all services is proportionate.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Proportionality applied to Aadhaar
The majority applied the proportionality framework from the privacy ruling: legitimate aim (welfare targeting), rational nexus, necessity, and balancing of rights against State interests.
Partial invalidation
Provisions enabling broad private corporate use of Aadhaar and certain storage/use practices were struck down or confined; core welfare use was sustained with safeguards.
Decision
Aadhaar for State welfare delivery largely upheld; several provisions curtailed. Distinct from the 2017 privacy holding, which remains the rights foundation.
Ratio decidendi
A biometric identity programme for welfare delivery can survive privacy scrutiny if it meets proportionality and is confined by law; measures that enable unrestricted commercial or surveillance use fail constitutional limits.
Exam points
- Distinct from Puttaswamy (Privacy) 2017 — this is the Aadhaar merits ruling.
- Proportionality test applied.
- Welfare use largely upheld; private/unrestricted use curtailed.
- Money Bill issue discussed (majority vs dissent).
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Aadhaar, Privacy, Article 21, Data