Ramana Dayaram Shetty v. International Airport Authority of India (1979)

Supreme Court of India · (1979) 3 SCC 489 · 3-Judge Bench

Summary

Seminal 3-judge bench precedent establishing the comprehensive tests for determining whether a statutory corporation or government company is an "instrumentality or agency of the State" under Article 12. Held that the State cannot act arbitrarily in awarding government contracts or tenders and is bound by the standards and norms it sets for itself.

Facts

  • The International Airport Authority of India (IAAI) issued a public tender notice inviting tenders for running a restaurant and snack bars at Bombay Airport.
  • The tender notice contained a mandatory condition of eligibility: the tenderer must be a registered second-class hotelier with at least 5 years experience in running a five-star hotel/restaurant.
  • Respondent No. 4, who had no experience in running 5-star hotels, submitted a tender and was accepted by IAAI, which relaxed the condition in his favor.
  • Ramana Dayaram Shetty, who did not bid because he assumed he was ineligible under the notice, challenged the award of the contract as arbitrary and discriminatory under Article 14.

Issues

  • Whether the International Airport Authority of India, a statutory corporation, is an "Authority" and an instrumentality of the State under Article 12 of the Constitution.
  • Whether the Government or its instrumentalities have unfettered discretion in awarding public contracts or are bound by the eligibility criteria published in the tender notice.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Cumulative tests for determining State instrumentality under Article 12

Bhagwati, J. formulated the cumulative tests: (1) Entire share capital held by the Government; (2) Deep and pervasive State control; (3) Extensive financial assistance meeting expenditure; (4) Monopoly status conferred or protected by State; (5) Functions of public importance closely related to governmental functions; and (6) Department of Government transferred to a corporation. IAAI satisfied these tests and was held to be an "instrumentality of the State".

An authority is bound by the rules it sets for itself

The government cannot act like a private individual in giving largesse or awarding contracts. It is an established principle of administrative law that an authority is bound by the standards and norms it sets for itself. If it sets down an eligibility standard in a tender notice, it cannot arbitrarily depart from it to favor a preferred bidder.

Decision

Appeal dismissed on the ground of delay and laches (the successful bidder had invested heavily and operated for over a year), but the legal challenge was fully upheld. The action of IAAI in relaxing the condition was declared arbitrary and violative of Article 14.

Ratio decidendi

A statutory corporation or government entity is an instrumentality of the State under Article 12 if the State exercises deep and pervasive control. The State and its instrumentalities do not possess unguided discretion in awarding contracts, tenders, or largesse; they are bound by the equality mandate of Article 14 and must adhere strictly to the eligibility criteria prescribed in the tender notice.

Exam points

  • Laid down the 6 cumulative tests for determining "instrumentality of the State" under Article 12.
  • Enunciated the principle that the executive is bound by the standards it sets for itself in tender notices.
  • Adopted and summarized in Ajay Hasia (1981).

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Article 12, Article 14, Administrative Law, Tenders

All judgments