Rameshwar v. State of Rajasthan (1952)

Supreme Court of India · 1952 AIR 54 · 3-Judge Bench

Summary

Classical judgment by Vivian Bose, J. defining the legal principles governing child witnesses and corroboration of prosecutrix testimony. Held that corroboration is not an inflexible rule of law but a rule of prudence; an omission by a Magistrate to administer an oath to a child does not render the testimony inadmissible under Section 118 Evidence Act (Section 124 BSA) if the child possesses sufficient intellectual capacity.

Facts

  • The appellant Rameshwar was convicted under Section 376 IPC for raping a young girl aged about 7 to 8 years.
  • The trial court examined the child witness without administering an oath because of her tender age, but recorded that she understood the duty of speaking the truth.
  • The conviction was based on her testimony corroborated by her immediate complaint to her mother and medical evidence.
  • The High Court affirmed the conviction. In appeal to the Supreme Court, the appellant argued that child testimony without oath was illegal and that uncorroborated prosecutrix evidence could not sustain a conviction.

Issues

  • Whether the testimony of a child witness recorded without an oath is admissible under Section 118 of the Indian Evidence Act.
  • What is the true nature and scope of the rule requiring corroboration of the testimony of a prosecutrix in sexual assault trials.

Provisions involved

  • Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 / IEA — s. Section 118 IEA / Section 124 BSA — Who may testify / Competency of witnesses
  • Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 / IEA — s. Section 133 & 114(b) IEA / Section 138 & 119 BSA — Accomplice testimony and presumption of corroboration

Reasoning

Competency of child witnesses under Section 118

Vivian Bose, J. held that competency under Section 118 Evidence Act depends upon intellectual capacity, not physical age. If a child understands questions and gives rational answers, their evidence is admissible. Omission to administer an oath does not affect admissibility, though it may go to credibility.

Corroboration is a rule of prudence, not law

The Court laid down the classic English rule from Rex v. Baskerville: Corroboration is not an inflexible rule of law but a prudent rule of practice. A prosecutrix is not an accomplice. The rule requires independent evidence confirming in some material particular not only that the crime was committed, but also connecting the accused with the crime.

Previous statement as corroboration under Section 157

The Court held that an immediate complaint made by the child to her mother shortly after the incident is admissible as conduct under Section 8 and constitutes valid corroboration of her testimony under Section 157 Evidence Act.

Decision

Appeal dismissed. Conviction and sentence under Section 376 IPC affirmed.

Ratio decidendi

Under Section 118 of the Indian Evidence Act (Section 124 BSA), intellectual capacity to understand questions and give rational answers is the sole test of competency of a witness; omission to administer an oath does not render a child testimony inadmissible. In sexual offences, the prosecutrix is a victim and not an accomplice; corroboration of her testimony is a rule of prudence, not an inflexible requirement of law, and independent evidence confirming the crime and connecting the accused in any material particular is sufficient.

Exam points

  • Vivian Bose, J. classical formulation of corroboration rule from Rex v. Baskerville.
  • Competency test for child witnesses under Section 118 IEA / Section 124 BSA.
  • Distinction between a prosecutrix and an accomplice under Section 133 / Section 114(b).

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, BSA, IEA, Section 118, Section 133, Child Witness, Corroboration

All judgments