Randhir Singh v. Union of India (1982)

Supreme Court of India · (1982) 1 SCC 618 · Three-Judge Bench · 1982-02-22

Summary

The Supreme Court recognised equal pay for equal work as a constitutional goal capable of enforcement in appropriate cases and examined whether similarly situated drivers could be denied parity in pay scales without a rational basis.

Facts

  • The petitioner was a driver constable in the Delhi Police Force and challenged the disparity between his pay scale and that of drivers performing comparable work in other government services.
  • Representations seeking parity had not resulted in equivalent pay.
  • The Court considered the relationship between Articles 14, 16 and 39(d) and the principle of equal pay for equal work.

Issues

  • Whether the petitioner was entitled to equal pay with drivers performing substantially similar duties.
  • Whether equal pay for equal work is merely a directive principle or can inform enforceable equality review.
  • What comparison is required before directing pay parity.

Reasoning

Equal pay as a constitutional objective

The Court treated the principle of equal pay for equal work as a constitutional goal that can inform judicial review where employees perform substantially equal work under comparable conditions.

Substance over nomenclature

Pay parity depends on the nature of duties, responsibilities and relevant service conditions rather than job titles alone.

Qualified application

The principle does not require identical pay for every superficially similar post; a rational and relevant distinction may justify different scales.

Decision

The Court granted relief to the petitioner and directed appropriate pay parity in accordance with its assessment of the comparable work and applicable service conditions.

Ratio decidendi

The constitutional commitment to equality, read with the directive of equal pay for equal work, can support judicial relief where substantially equal work is performed under comparable conditions. The inquiry is substantive and depends on duties, responsibilities and relevant service factors.

Exam points

  • Equal pay for equal work is not applied mechanically from job titles.
  • The comparison concerns duties, responsibilities and relevant service conditions.
  • Randhir Singh is a leading Indian authority on the enforceability of the equal-pay principle.

Tags: labour, equal-pay, service-law, wages

All judgments