R.C. Cooper v. Union of India (1970)
Supreme Court of India · (1970) 1 SCC 248 · 11-Judge Constitution Bench
Summary
The Court struck down the Banking Companies (Acquisition and Transfer of Undertakings) Ordinance/Act of 1969 insofar as the compensation scheme was illusory, and held that a law can be tested under multiple fundamental rights; the Gopalan theory of isolated silos was rejected in approach, paving the way for Maneka Gandhi.
Facts
- The Union nationalised fourteen major commercial banks through an ordinance and later an Act.
- Shareholders and banks challenged the acquisition and the adequacy of compensation.
Issues
- Whether the nationalisation law violated Articles 14, 19 and 31.
- Whether fundamental rights operate in separate compartments.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Interrelationship of fundamental rights
The Court rejected the rigid Gopalan approach that each fundamental right occupies a separate compartment; a law can be tested under more than one Article.
Illusory compensation
The compensation scheme was held not to meet constitutional requirements, rendering the acquisition scheme vulnerable.
Decision
The impugned nationalisation measure was struck down on compensation and rights grounds. Parliament later re-enacted nationalisation with adjustments. Doctrinally, R.C. Cooper is a bridge to Maneka Gandhi’s integrated reading of rights.
Ratio decidendi
A law abridging freedoms may be examined under multiple fundamental-rights provisions; acquisition accompanied by illusory compensation does not satisfy constitutional requirements.
Exam points
- Bank Nationalisation Case.
- Rejected Gopalan silos; rights read together.
- Illusory compensation fatal.
- Doctrinal prelude to Maneka Gandhi.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Property, Article 19, Nationalisation