R.G. Anand v. Deluxe Films (1978)

Supreme Court of India · (1978) 4 SCC 118

Summary

The Supreme Court formulated the leading Indian approach distinguishing an unprotectable idea from protectable expression and assessing whether the later work amounts to an infringement of copyright.

Facts

  • R.G. Anand, a playwright, alleged that a later film substantially reproduced his play.
  • The dispute required the Court to distinguish common ideas or themes from protectable expression and to assess substantial similarity.

Issues

  • Whether copyright can subsist in an idea or theme as such.
  • What test should be applied to determine infringement between a play and a film.

Provisions involved

  • Copyright Act, 1957 — s. Section 13 — Works in which copyright subsists
  • Copyright Act, 1957 — s. Section 14 — Meaning of copyright

Reasoning

Idea-expression distinction

Copyright protects original expression in a qualifying work, not a bare idea, theme or general concept capable of independent expression.

Overall similarity

The Court emphasised a practical comparison of the later work as a whole with the protected work to determine whether the later work has appropriated protected expression rather than merely a common idea.

Decision

The Court rejected copyright monopoly over ideas as such and applied the infringement analysis to the alleged copying of expression.

Ratio decidendi

Copyright protects original expression rather than ideas, and infringement is assessed by comparing the works to determine whether protected expression has been substantially reproduced.

Exam points

  • Idea versus expression.
  • Copyright infringement test.
  • Substantial similarity.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Copyright, IPR

All judgments