State of Bombay v. R.M.D. Chamarbaugwala (1957)

Supreme Court of India · 1957 AIR 699 · Constitution Bench (5 Judges)

Summary

Seminal 5-Judge Constitution Bench decision ruling that gambling competitions and prize contests of a gambling nature do not constitute "trade, commerce, or intercourse" within the meaning of Article 19(1)(g) or Article 301. Established that criminal, immoral, and pernicious activities are res extra commercium, and laid down the definitive rules governing the doctrine of severability.

Facts

  • The respondents ran prize competitions known as "crossword puzzles" through a weekly newspaper printed in Bangalore and circulated widely in the State of Bombay.
  • The State of Bombay amended the Bombay Lotteries and Prize Competitions Control and Tax Act, 1948 to tax and regulate prize competitions, including those conducted from outside the State.
  • The organizers challenged the Act, contending that the tax was an unconstitutional restriction on their freedom of trade and business under Article 19(1)(g) and on inter-state commerce under Article 301.
  • The Bombay High Court held that the tax breached Article 301. The State of Bombay appealed to the Supreme Court.

Issues

  • Whether gambling and prize competitions of a gambling nature are protected under Article 19(1)(g) or Article 301 as trade, commerce, or intercourse.
  • Whether the provisions regulating gambling competitions could be severed from those regulating competitions requiring substantial skill under the doctrine of severability.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Gambling is not trade or commerce

Das, C.J. observed that ancient Hindu scriptures, Roman law, and common law have universally condemned gambling as an unmitigated social evil. The Constitution-makers, having framed Directive Principles to promote a welfare state, could never have intended to elevate gambling, trafficking, or crime to the status of fundamental trade under Article 19(1)(g) or commercial intercourse under Article 301.

Doctrine of severability

The Court formulated the classical test of severability: If the valid and invalid parts of a statute are so distinct that after rejecting the invalid portion, what remains is an independent, complete, and workable code carrying out the legislative intent, the valid portion will be upheld.

Decision

Appeal allowed. Held that gambling activities are res extra commercium and not protected by Article 19(1)(g) or Article 301.

Ratio decidendi

Activities which are inherently vicious, pernicious, and immoral, such as gambling and lotteries, cannot be regarded as trade, commerce, or intercourse within the contemplation of Article 19(1)(g) or Article 301 of the Constitution of India. They are res extra commercium, and the Legislature is fully competent to tax, regulate, or suppress them without satisfying the tests of reasonable restrictions.

Exam points

  • Doctrine of Res Extra Commercium applied to gambling and lotteries.
  • Exclusion of gambling from Article 19(1)(g) and Article 301 freedom of trade.
  • Classical rules governing the Doctrine of Severability formulated by Das, C.J.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Article 301, Doctrine of Severability, Gambling

All judgments