Rudul Sah v. State of Bihar (1983)

Supreme Court of India · (1983) 4 SCC 141 · 3-Judge Bench

Summary

The Supreme Court inaugurated public law damages for constitutional tort in India, ordering the State of Bihar to pay Rs. 35,000 as compensation to Rudul Sah, who had been illegally kept in prison for more than 14 years after being acquitted by the Sessions Court. The Court held that monetary compensation is a necessary and effective palliative remedy to enforce Article 21 against State lawlessness.

Facts

  • Rudul Sah was tried for murder and acquitted by the Sessions Court of Muzaffarpur on 3 June 1968, which directed his immediate release.
  • Despite the acquittal, he was languishing in jail for more than 14 years until released in October 1982 after a habeas corpus petition was filed.
  • He approached the Supreme Court under Article 32 demanding immediate release, rehabilitation, medical treatment, and exemplary compensation from the State.

Issues

  • Whether the Supreme Court can award monetary compensation under Article 32 for violation of the fundamental right to life and liberty under Article 21.
  • Whether the petitioner must be relegated solely to an ordinary civil suit for damages for false imprisonment.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Monetary compensation as a constitutional remedy under Article 32

Chandrachud, C.J. held that Article 21 would be denuded of its significant content if the power of the Court were limited merely to passing orders of release. The Court can grant monetary compensation in exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 32 to repair gross violations of fundamental rights.

Palliative and non-exclusionary remedy

The grant of compensation under Article 32 does not bar the petitioner from pursuing an ordinary civil suit for damages, but provides immediate palliative relief against administrative callousness.

Decision

State of Bihar directed to pay Rs. 35,000 compensation in addition to Rs. 5,000 already paid.

Ratio decidendi

Monetary compensation can be granted under Article 32 for deprivation of personal liberty under Article 21 caused by unlawful and unconstitutional detention by State authorities.

Exam points

  • Inaugurated public law compensation for constitutional tort in India.
  • Petitioner detained for 14 years after acquittal.
  • Affirmed that Article 32 powers extend to awarding financial reparation.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Article 32, Article 21, Compensation, Illegal Detention

All judgments