Sajjan Kumar v. CBI (2010)

Supreme Court of India · (2010) 9 SCC 368 · 2-Judge Bench

Summary

Comprehensive Supreme Court decision synthesizing thirty years of jurisprudence on framing of charges and discharge under Sections 227 and 228 CrPC. Arising out of the 1984 Anti-Sikh Riots prosecutions against politician Sajjan Kumar, the Court summarized eight comprehensive rules governing judicial discretion at the threshold of trial.

Facts

  • Following the assassination of Prime Minister Indira Gandhi, violent anti-Sikh riots erupted in Delhi in November 1984.
  • Decades later, based on the Justice Nanavati Commission report, the CBI registered cases and filed chargesheets against former Member of Parliament Sajjan Kumar for murder, rioting, and promoting communal enmity.
  • The Special CBI Judge framed charges under Sections 302, 147, 148, 149, 153A, and 120B IPC.
  • Sajjan Kumar challenged the framing of charges, arguing that earlier police inquiries had closed the case and delayed witness statements were unreliable.

Issues

  • What are the comprehensive legal principles governing discharge and framing of charges under Sections 227 and 228 CrPC.
  • Can delayed statements or prior closure reports justify discharging an accused when eyewitness affidavits raise grave suspicion.

Provisions involved

  • Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 / CrPC — s. Section 227 & 228 CrPC / Section 250 & 251 BNSS — Discharge and framing of charge in Sessions Trial

Reasoning

Synthesis of Eight Principles on Charge Framing

Sathasivam, J. codified 8 principles: (1) Judge has power to sift materials to determine prima facie case; (2) Grave suspicion warrants charge; (3) Cannot conduct a mini-trial; (4) Court cannot act as a post office; (5) If two views are equally possible and materials give rise to only mere suspicion, discharge is proper; (6) Detailed evaluation of witness veracity is impermissible at charge stage; (7) Defence materials cannot be looked into unless of unimpeachable character; (8) Delay in lodging FIR or recording statements cannot be a ground for discharge if prima facie allegations exist.

Decision

Appeal dismissed. Order framing charges under Sections 302/149/120B IPC affirmed; trial directed to proceed expeditiously.

Ratio decidendi

At the stage of framing charges under Sections 227 and 228 CrPC, the court must consider whether there is ground for presuming that the accused has committed the offence. The court cannot appreciate witness veracity, reconcile contradictions, or accept delay as a ground for discharge when the materials disclose a grave suspicion of complicity in serious offences.

Exam points

  • The modern eight-point synthesis on framing of charges under Sections 227/228 CrPC.
  • Eyewitness veracity cannot be adjudicated at the stage of discharge.
  • Delay in recording statements is a matter for trial, not a threshold bar.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, CrPC, Section 227, Section 228, BNSS 250, Charge Guidelines, Sathasivam J

All judgments