Sajjan Singh v. State of Rajasthan (1965)
Supreme Court of India · AIR 1965 SC 845 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench
Summary
The Constitution Bench by 3:2 majority reaffirmed the Sankari Prasad doctrine upholding the Constitution (17th Amendment) Act, 1964. However, the separate opinions of Hidayatullah, J. and Mudholkar, J. expressed profound doubts, questioning whether fundamental features of the Constitution could be changed, thus sowing the intellectual seeds of the Basic Structure doctrine.
Facts
- Parliament passed the Constitution (17th Amendment) Act, 1964 adding 44 State agrarian enactments to the Ninth Schedule to insulate them from judicial scrutiny.
- Petitioners challenged the 17th Amendment, contending that it affected the jurisdiction of High Courts under Article 226 and therefore required ratification by State Legislatures under the proviso to Article 368.
Issues
- Whether the 17th Amendment Act, 1964 directly affected Article 226 requiring ratification by State Legislatures under Article 368 proviso.
- Whether Sankari Prasad was correctly decided in holding that Part III could be amended under Article 368.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Majority reasoning upholding 17th Amendment
Gajendragadkar, C.J. held that the pith and substance of the 17th Amendment was agrarian reform, not curtailment of High Court jurisdiction under Article 226, and reaffirmed Sankari Prasad.
Sowing the seeds of the Basic Structure
Mudholkar, J. and Hidayatullah, J. raised momentous doubts whether Parliament could alter the "basic features" or "essential framework" of the Constitution under Article 368.
Decision
The 17th Constitutional Amendment was upheld as constitutionally valid.
Ratio decidendi
An amendment directly affecting property laws does not require ratification under Article 368 proviso if its incidental effect on Article 226 does not alter the High Courts’ constitutional framework.
Exam points
- 17th Amendment upheld by 3:2 majority.
- Mudholkar, J. coined the phrase "basic features" of the Constitution.
- Hidayatullah, J. doubted whether Fundamental Rights could be the plaything of a special majority.
- Direct conceptual precursor to Kesavananda Bharati.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Amendment, Basic Structure Genesis