Sarla Mudgal v. Union of India (1995)

Supreme Court of India · (1995) 3 SCC 635 · 2-Judge Bench

Summary

The Supreme Court held that a Hindu marriage solemnized under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 can be dissolved only on the grounds specified under that Act. A Hindu husband cannot circumvent the monogamy rule by converting to Islam and contracting a second marriage; such second marriage is void under Section 11 of HMA and Section 494 IPC (now Section 82 BNS), and the converting husband is guilty of bigamy.

Facts

  • Jitender Mathur, married to Meena Mathur under Hindu rites, converted to Islam, took the name Jamil Ahmed, and married another woman, Sunita (Fatima), without divorcing his first wife.
  • Several similar petitions were filed by Hindu wives whose husbands converted to Islam solely for the purpose of contracting a second marriage to evade the statutory ban on bigamy.

Issues

  • Whether a Hindu husband, married under Hindu law, can solemnize a second marriage by converting to Islam without dissolving his first marriage.
  • Whether the converting husband is liable for bigamy under Section 494 IPC.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Survival of Hindu marriage post-conversion

Kuldip Singh, J. held that a marriage celebrated under Hindu law continues to subsist notwithstanding conversion. Hindu law does not recognize apostasy as an automatic dissolution of marriage; it is merely a ground for the other spouse to seek divorce under Section 13(1)(ii).

Bigamy under Section 494 IPC

Since the first marriage continues to subsist in the eyes of law, contracting a second marriage during the lifetime of the first spouse is void under Section 494 IPC, and the converting husband is punishable for bigamy.

Decision

Second marriage declared void; husband held liable for bigamy under Section 494 IPC; urged Union Government to examine Uniform Civil Code under Article 44.

Ratio decidendi

Conversion of a Hindu husband to Islam does not automatically dissolve his prior Hindu marriage; any second marriage contracted during the subsistence of the first is bigamous and void under Section 494 IPC.

Exam points

  • Conversion to Islam does not dissolve an existing Hindu marriage.
  • Second marriage during subsistence of first marriage is void under Section 494 IPC / Section 82 BNS.
  • Reiterated the need for a Uniform Civil Code under Article 44.
  • Affirmed by a larger bench in Lily Thomas (2000).

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Family Law, Bigamy, Section 494 IPC, BNS 82, Conversion

All judgments