Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation (2009)

Supreme Court of India · (2009) 6 SCC 121 · 2-Judge Bench

Summary

Locus classicus Supreme Court precedent standardizing the assessment of compensation in motor accident fatal claims under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. Formulated the definitive age-based Multiplier Table (18 to 5), standardized percentage deductions for personal and living expenses of the deceased based on the number of dependent family members, and established uniform rules for future prospects.

Facts

  • Rajinder Pal Verrma, a 38-year-old scientist working with the Indian Council of Agricultural Research (ICAR) earning Rs 3,402 per month, was killed in an accident caused by a rashly driven DTC bus in Delhi.
  • His widow, children, parents, and grandparents filed a claim petition before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (MACT).
  • The Tribunal awarded Rs 5.75 lakh, which the High Court enhanced to Rs 7.19 lakh.
  • The claimants appealed to the Supreme Court, contending that compensation had been assessed arbitrarily due to widely fluctuating formulas adopted by different courts across India.

Issues

  • How to establish uniform and standardized principles for calculating just compensation in motor accident fatal claims under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
  • What is the appropriate multiplier to be adopted for different age groups.
  • What are the standard deductions for the personal and living expenses of the deceased.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Standardized Multiplier Table based on age

Raveendran, J. harmonized the Second Schedule of the MV Act and earlier precedents, establishing a definitive multiplier table based on the age of the deceased: Age 21-25: Multiplier 18; Age 26-30: 17; Age 31-35: 16; Age 36-40: 15; Age 41-45: 14; Age 46-50: 13; Age 51-55: 11; Age 56-60: 9; Age 61-65: 7; Age above 65: 5.

Deductions for personal living expenses

The Court standardized personal expense deductions: (a) If the deceased was a bachelor: 50% deduction; (b) Where family dependents are 2 to 3: 1/3rd deduction; (c) Where dependents are 4 to 6: 1/4th deduction; (d) Where dependents exceed 6: 1/5th deduction.

Decision

Appeal allowed. Compensation enhanced to Rs 8.87 lakh with 6% interest. The standardized multiplier and deduction tables were made binding nationwide.

Ratio decidendi

Just compensation under Section 168 of the Motor Vehicles Act must be assessed through uniform, standardized rules. The age of the deceased determines the multiplier from the authoritative table (18 to 5). Deductions for personal living expenses are fixed at 1/3rd for 2-3 dependents, 1/4th for 4-6 dependents, and 50% for bachelors.

Exam points

  • The foundational authority for the "Multiplier Method" in MACT motor accident claims.
  • Prescribed the definitive multiplier chart (18 down to 5) based on age brackets.
  • Standardized deductions for personal living expenses (1/2, 1/3, 1/4, 1/5).

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Torts, MACT, Motor Vehicles Act, Multiplier, Sarla Verma

All judgments