Sarojini Ramaswami v. Union of India (1992)

Supreme Court of India · (1992) 4 SCC 506 · Constitution Bench (5 Judges)

Summary

Constitution Bench ruling examining the constitutional machinery for the removal of a Supreme Court judge under Article 124(4)/(5) and the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968. Held that the statutory investigation by the Inquiry Committee is a preliminary statutory process culminating in a report to Parliament; the concerned Judge has no right to challenge the Inquiry Committee report under Article 32 before Parliament completes the impeachment process.

Facts

  • An Inquiry Committee constituted under the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968 found Justice V. Ramaswami, a sitting Judge of the Supreme Court, guilty of several charges of misbehavior involving financial irregularities during his tenure as Chief Justice of Punjab & Haryana High Court.
  • The petitioner Sarojini Ramaswami (wife of the Judge) filed a writ petition under Article 32 seeking a copy of the Inquiry Committee report and challenging its findings prior to parliamentary consideration.
  • The petitioner contended that principles of natural justice entitled the Judge to challenge adverse findings in the Supreme Court before Parliament debated the motion for removal.

Issues

  • Whether a sitting judge found guilty of misbehavior by an Inquiry Committee under the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968 can seek judicial review of the report under Article 32 before Parliament debates removal.
  • At what stage does judicial review become available in the constitutional process of removing a judge under Article 124(4)?

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Two-stage constitutional process of removal

Verma, J. (for the majority) held that the process of removal of a judge consists of two distinct stages: (1) the statutory stage of investigation by an Inquiry Committee under the 1968 Act; and (2) the parliamentary stage where both Houses of Parliament debate and vote by special majority under Article 124(4).

Timing of judicial review

The Court held that judicial review is barred at the interlocutory stage of the Inquiry Committee report. If Parliament rejects the motion, the matter ends. If Parliament adopts the motion and the President passes an order of removal, judicial review becomes available to the removed judge after the order of removal is made.

Decision

Writ petition dismissed. Held that judicial review cannot be invoked against an Inquiry Committee report prior to parliamentary debate and presidential order.

Ratio decidendi

In the scheme of removal of a Supreme Court or High Court judge under Article 124(4) and Article 124(5) of the Constitution read with the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968, judicial review cannot be invoked midway to challenge the findings of the Inquiry Committee before Parliament considers the report. Judicial review is available only after an order of removal is passed by the President following an address by Parliament.

Exam points

  • Two-stage process of judicial removal: statutory inquiry followed by parliamentary address.
  • Non-maintainability of judicial review midway before parliamentary consideration.
  • Availability of judicial review only after the President passes the order of removal.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Article 124, Removal of Judges, Judicial Independence

All judgments