Satish Chander Ahuja v. Sneha Ahuja (2021)
Supreme Court of India · (2021) 1 SCC 414 · 3-Judge Bench
Summary
Landmark 3-judge bench decision overturning the restrictive interpretation of "shared household" laid down in S.R. Batra v. Taruna Batra (2007). Held that under Section 2(s) and Section 17 of the Domestic Violence Act, 2005, a woman has a right of residence in a property belonging to her in-laws if she lived there in a domestic relationship, even if the husband has no legal share or ownership in the property.
Facts
- The father-in-law, Satish Chander Ahuja, filed a suit for mandatory injunction seeking the eviction of his daughter-in-law Sneha Ahuja from his self-acquired property.
- The daughter-in-law resisted eviction, contending that the premises constituted her "shared household" under Section 2(s) of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005, giving her a statutory right of residence under Section 17.
- The trial court passed a decree of eviction relying on S.R. Batra (2007), which held that a house owned exclusively by parents-in-law cannot be a shared household.
- The High Court set aside the decree and remanded the matter, leading to the Supreme Court appeal.
Issues
- What is the true statutory scope of "shared household" under Section 2(s) of the DV Act.
- Whether the restrictive rule in S.R. Batra v. Taruna Batra, which excluded in-laws self-acquired property from shared household, was correctly decided.
Provisions involved
- Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 — s. Sections 2(s), 17 & 19 — Definition of shared household and right to reside in shared household
Reasoning
Overruling S.R. Batra v. Taruna Batra
Ashok Bhushan, J. held that the interpretation given in S.R. Batra was too narrow and frustrated the remedial purpose of the DV Act. Section 2(s) does not require that the shared household must belong to the husband or be joint family property. It suffices if the aggrieved woman lived in the property in a domestic relationship.
Balancing rights of senior citizens and daughters-in-law
The Court held that in eviction suits filed by senior citizens against daughters-in-law, civil courts must balance the rights of elderly parents with the statutory residence rights of the daughter-in-law under Section 17 DV Act, without passing mechanical eviction decrees.
Decision
Appeal dismissed. S.R. Batra overruled. Held that a woman can claim right of residence under Section 17 DV Act in property exclusively owned by in-laws if she lived there in a domestic relationship.
Ratio decidendi
Under Sections 2(s) and 17 of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005, a "shared household" includes any property where the aggrieved woman has lived at any stage in a domestic relationship, irrespective of whether the husband holds any proprietary right or title in the premises. S.R. Batra v. Taruna Batra is overruled.
Exam points
- Overruled S.R. Batra v. Taruna Batra (2007).
- Expounded definition of "shared household" under Section 2(s) DV Act.
- Harmonized Maintenance of Parents Act with the Domestic Violence Act.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, DV Act, Section 17, Shared Household, Women Rights, Family Law