Shafi Mohammad v. State of H.P. (2018)

Supreme Court of India · (2018) 2 SCC 801 · 2-Judge Bench

Summary

Significant Supreme Court decision holding that the requirement of producing a certificate under Section 65B(4) Evidence Act is not mandatory where the party seeking to produce electronic evidence is not in possession or control of the device. (Note: Substantially clarified and overruled by the 3-judge bench in Arjun Panditrao Khotkar in 2020).

Facts

  • In a criminal prosecution in Himachal Pradesh, the State relied on CCTV footage and digital call records.
  • The trial court and appellate authorities encountered conflicting interpretations of the 3-judge bench ruling in Anvar P.V. regarding whether third parties without device custody could produce electronic evidence without a Section 65B certificate.

Issues

  • Whether a Section 65B(4) certificate is an absolute mandatory condition precedent even when the electronic device is not in possession or control of the party producing it.
  • Whether procedural technicalities can shut out relevant electronic evidence in the interest of justice.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Dispensation of certificate for third parties without device custody

The 2-judge bench held that where a party producing electronic evidence is not in possession of the electronic device, Section 65B(4) certificate is not mandatory, and secondary evidence can be admitted under Sections 63 and 65 of the Evidence Act.

Decision

Directions issued permitting secondary electronic evidence without Section 65B(4) certificate when the party lacks device possession. (Overruled on this point by Arjun Panditrao Khotkar in 2020).

Ratio decidendi

A party who is not in custody of the electronic device cannot be compelled to produce a Section 65B(4) certificate, and may prove electronic secondary evidence under ordinary rules of evidence.

Exam points

  • Important milestone in electronic evidence jurisprudence.
  • Held Section 65B(4) directory for non-device holders, but later overruled by Arjun Panditrao Khotkar (2020).
  • Under BSA 2023 Section 63, electronic records are directly recognized with streamlined certification.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Evidence, Section 65B, BSA 63, Electronic Records

All judgments