Shantistar Builders v. Narayan Khimalal Totame (1990)

Supreme Court of India · (1990) 1 SCC 520

Summary

The Supreme Court treated adequate shelter as an important component of a dignified life and discussed the State’s role in housing and urban development.

Facts

  • The dispute concerned housing and development conditions affecting persons seeking residential accommodation.
  • The Court examined housing needs in the context of the right to life and human dignity.

Issues

  • Whether the right to shelter forms part of the right to life.
  • How should housing needs be considered in development policy?

Provisions involved

  • Housing and Urban Development Law Principles — Right to shelter as an aspect of dignified life

Reasoning

Shelter and dignity

The Court observed that food, clothing and shelter are basic necessities and that meaningful enjoyment of life includes access to reasonable shelter.

Decision

The Court recognised the importance of housing and shelter in interpreting the right to life.

Ratio decidendi

The constitutional understanding of dignified life includes basic necessities such as shelter, subject to the legal and factual context of the claim.

Exam points

  • Important early right-to-shelter authority.
  • Connects housing with human dignity.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Right to Shelter, Housing

All judgments