Shatrughan Chauhan v. Union of India (2014)

Supreme Court of India · (2014) 3 SCC 1 · 3-Judge Bench

Summary

Historic 3-judge bench judgment commuted the death sentences of 15 death-row convicts to life imprisonment on grounds of inordinate, unexplained executive delay (ranging from 1.5 to 12 years) in disposing of their mercy petitions under Article 72/161. Formulated 12 binding guidelines governing the treatment of condemned prisoners, including a mandatory minimum 14-day gap between mercy rejection and execution.

Facts

  • Shatrughan Chauhan and other condemned convicts (including forest brigand Veerappan associates) filed writ petitions under Article 32.
  • Their mercy petitions had been kept pending by the Ministry of Home Affairs and the President of India for periods between 6 to 12 years without explanation.
  • The petitioners contended that undergoing agonizing wait on death row for a decade under shadow of the gallows constituted torture violating Article 21.

Issues

  • Whether inordinate and unexplained delay in deciding mercy petitions is a supervening ground for commuting death sentence to life under Article 21.
  • Whether the nature of the crime (even terrorism or gruesome murder) deprives a convict of Article 21 protections against executive delay.
  • What procedural safeguards must be followed before executing a death sentence.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Article 21 applies to condemned convicts till their last breath

Sathasivam, C.J. held that Article 21 inheres in every human being till their last breath. An inordinate, unexplained delay in disposing of a mercy petition is a supervening circumstance that renders execution harsh, cruel, and arbitrary. The nature of the crime cannot be a ground to deny Article 21 protections.

12 mandatory nationwide guidelines

The Court mandated: (1) Rejection of mercy petition must be communicated in writing to the convict and family; (2) Minimum 14-day gap between communication of rejection and execution date; (3) Solitary confinement before rejection of mercy petition is illegal; (4) Mandatory mental health evaluation; (5) Right to legal aid and copies of all documents.

Decision

Writ petitions allowed. Death sentences of 15 condemned convicts commuted to imprisonment for life. 12 mandatory execution guidelines formulated.

Ratio decidendi

Under Article 21 of the Constitution, inordinate, unexplained, and unreasonable delay by the President or Governor in deciding mercy petitions under Articles 72/161 is a supervening factor that justifies commuting the death sentence to imprisonment for life, irrespective of the gravity of the crime. Execution without communicating rejection or without a minimum 14-day notice is unconstitutional.

Exam points

  • The modern Magna Carta of death penalty administration in India.
  • Mandatory minimum 14-day gap between mercy rejection and execution.
  • Declared solitary confinement prior to mercy rejection unconstitutional.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Article 21, Article 72, Death Penalty, Shatrughan Chauhan, Human Rights

All judgments