State of U.P. v. Singhara Singh (1964)

Supreme Court of India · AIR 1964 SC 358 · 3-Judge Bench

Summary

Classic Supreme Court ruling incorporating the English principle of Taylor v. Taylor into Indian procedural jurisprudence. Held that where a power is given to do a certain thing in a certain way, the thing must be done in that way or not at all, and other methods of performance are necessarily forbidden. Consequently, oral evidence of a Magistrate is inadmissible to prove a confession not recorded in compliance with Section 164 CrPC.

Facts

  • Singhara Singh was prosecuted for the murder of an Assistant Station Master at a railway station.
  • During investigation, a Second Class Magistrate not specially empowered by the State Government under Section 164 CrPC recorded the confession of the accused.
  • At trial, realizing the Magistrate lacked statutory empowerment under Section 164, the prosecution produced the Magistrate as a witness to give oral evidence of the confession under Sections 17, 21, and 29 of the Evidence Act.
  • The trial court convicted the accused, but the High Court held the oral evidence inadmissible and acquitted him.
  • The State appealed to the Supreme Court.

Issues

  • Can a confession not recorded in conformity with Section 164 CrPC be proved by oral testimony of the recording Magistrate.
  • What is the scope of the rule in Taylor v. Taylor in criminal procedure.

Provisions involved

  • Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 / CrPC — s. Section 164 CrPC / Section 183 BNSS — Recording of confessions and statements by Magistrate

Reasoning

Application of the Taylor v. Taylor doctrine

Sarkar, J. adopted the principle laid down in Taylor v. Taylor (1875) and Nazir Ahmad (1936): "Where a power is given to do a certain thing in a certain way, the thing must be done in that way or not at all and that other methods of performance are necessarily forbidden."

Oral evidence of confession completely barred

Section 164 CrPC prescribes a solemn statutory procedure for recording confessions with mandatory warnings that the accused is not bound to confess. If oral evidence of unrecorded or improperly recorded confessions were permitted, the entire protection granted by Section 164 would be rendered completely illusory.

Decision

Appeal dismissed. Acquittal upheld. Oral evidence of Magistrate regarding the confession held inadmissible.

Ratio decidendi

Where a statute confers a power on a public authority to do a specific act in a prescribed manner (such as recording a confession under Section 164 CrPC), it must be done in that manner or not at all; all other modes of performance are impliedly excluded. Oral evidence of a Magistrate is wholly inadmissible to prove a confession recorded without statutory authority.

Exam points

  • The definitive Indian judgment applying the Taylor v. Taylor rule.
  • Mandatory nature of Section 164 CrPC (now Section 183 BNSS).
  • Inadmissibility of oral evidence to cure jurisdictional defects in recording confessions.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, CrPC, Section 164, BNSS 183, Evidence, Taylor v. Taylor, Confession

All judgments