S.R. Bommai v. Union of India (1994)
Supreme Court of India · (1994) 3 SCC 1 · 9-Judge Constitution Bench
Summary
A 9-Judge Bench held that a Presidential Proclamation under Article 356 is justiciable, that secularism is part of the basic structure, and that the proper test of majority support of a State government is normally a floor test on the floor of the Legislative Assembly.
Facts
- Several State governments were dismissed under Article 356 in the late 1980s and early 1990s, including the Bommai government in Karnataka.
- Petitioners challenged the validity of the Proclamations and the scope of judicial review over the President’s satisfaction.
- The Court examined the federal balance, the role of the Governor’s report, and the relevance of secularism after the demolition of the Babri Masjid in related contexts.
Issues
- Whether a Proclamation under Article 356 is amenable to judicial review.
- What is the proper mode of determining whether a State government has lost majority support.
- Whether secularism forms part of the basic structure so as to justify action under Article 356.
Provisions involved
- Constitution of India — Art. Article 356 — Provisions in case of failure of constitutional machinery in States
- Constitution of India — Art. Article 74 — Council of Ministers to aid and advise President
Reasoning
Justiciability of Article 356
The President’s satisfaction is not beyond judicial review. Courts may examine whether the Proclamation is based on any relevant material, is issued mala fide, or is based on wholly extraneous or irrelevant grounds.
Floor test as the proper rule
Where the issue is loss of majority, the Court preferred a floor test in the Legislative Assembly over private assessment by the Governor, subject to exceptional circumstances.
Secularism and basic structure
Secularism is a basic feature of the Constitution. A State government acting contrary to the secular constitutional creed may invite action under Article 356 on the basis of relevant material.
Decision
The Court clarified the limited but real scope of judicial review over Article 356 Proclamations, emphasised the floor test, and recognised secularism as part of the basic structure relevant to federal emergency powers.
Ratio decidendi
Presidential power under Article 356 is subject to judicial review on grounds of relevant material, mala fides and extraneous considerations; democratic legitimacy of a State ministry is primarily determined by a floor test.
Exam points
- Article 356 Proclamation is justiciable (not a political thicket in absolute terms).
- Floor test is the primary method to test majority.
- Secularism is part of the basic structure.
- Mala fides and absence of relevant material can invalidate a Proclamation.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Article 356, Federalism, Basic Structure, Secularism