Standard Chartered Bank v. Directorate of Enforcement (2005)
Supreme Court of India · (2005) 4 SCC 530 · Constitution Bench (5 Judges)
Summary
Authoritative 5-Judge Constitution Bench decision settling the law of corporate criminal liability in India. Held that a company or corporate body can be prosecuted and held criminally liable for statutory offences even where the statute prescribes a mandatory minimum punishment of imprisonment and fine; in such cases, the court will impose the sentence of fine on the corporation.
Facts
- Standard Chartered Bank and other corporate banking entities were prosecuted for criminal violations under Section 56 of the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973 (FERA).
- Section 56 FERA prescribed that upon conviction, the offender "shall be punishable with imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than six months and also with fine".
- The bank contended that because a company is a juristic entity that cannot be physically imprisoned, and the statute mandates both imprisonment and fine, a company cannot be prosecuted at all for such offences.
- A 5-Judge Constitution Bench was constituted to resolve whether corporations enjoy blanket immunity from prosecution for offences prescribing mandatory custodial sentences.
Issues
- Whether a company or corporation can be prosecuted for an offence where the statute prescribes a mandatory minimum sentence of imprisonment and fine.
- Whether the inability of a court to impose physical imprisonment on a corporate entity grants it immunity from criminal prosecution.
Provisions involved
- Companies Act / IPC — s. Section 11 IPC / Section 2(20) Companies Act — Definition of person and corporate personality
Reasoning
No corporate immunity from criminal prosecution
Srikrishna, J. (for the majority) held that there is no immunity to companies from being prosecuted for serious statutory or penal offences. Section 11 of the IPC defines "person" to include a company. If a company could not be prosecuted for an offence requiring imprisonment and fine, corporations could commit economic crimes with complete impunity.
Doctrine of severability in sentencing juristic persons
The Court held that the maxim lex non cogit ad impossibilia (the law does not compel the impossible) applies. Where the statute mandates imprisonment and fine, the court can impose the custodial sentence on natural persons and the sentence of fine on the juristic company.
Decision
Appeals dismissed. Held that Standard Chartered Bank and other corporations can be prosecuted under Section 56 FERA and penalized with fine.
Ratio decidendi
A corporation or corporate entity can be lawfully prosecuted and convicted for statutory criminal offences even where the prescribed statutory penalty includes a mandatory term of imprisonment and fine. Applying the maxim lex non cogit ad impossibilia, the court cannot impose physical imprisonment on a juristic entity, but the court is fully competent to impose the sentence of fine. Corporate entities enjoy no immunity from criminal prosecution.
Exam points
- Establishment of corporate criminal liability in India by 5-Judge Constitution Bench.
- Application of maxim: Lex non cogit ad impossibilia to criminal sentencing of corporations.
- Rejection of corporate immunity for offences with mandatory imprisonment.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Company Law, Corporate Criminal Liability, FERA, IPC, Section 11 IPC