Sub-Committee on Judicial Accountability v. Union of India (1991)
Supreme Court of India · (1991) 4 SCC 699 · Constitution Bench (5 Judges)
Summary
Historic 5-Judge Constitution Bench decision holding that a notice of motion for presenting an address to the President for the removal of a Supreme Court or High Court judge does not lapse upon the dissolution of the House of the People (Lok Sabha). Clarified that the statutory investigation by an Inquiry Committee under the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968 is an independent statutory proceeding that survives dissolution.
Facts
- A notice of motion signed by 108 members of the 9th Lok Sabha for the removal of Justice V. Ramaswami was admitted by the Speaker of the Lok Sabha, who constituted a 3-member Inquiry Committee under Section 3 of the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968.
- Before the Inquiry Committee could submit its report, the 9th Lok Sabha was dissolved and the 10th Lok Sabha was elected.
- The Union Government took the stand that upon dissolution of the Lok Sabha, the motion for removal lapsed under Article 107 of the Constitution and the Inquiry Committee became functus officio.
- The Sub-Committee on Judicial Accountability filed a writ petition under Article 32 seeking a declaration that the motion and inquiry did not lapse.
Issues
- Whether a motion for the removal of a judge admitted by the Speaker under the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968 lapses upon the dissolution of the Lok Sabha.
- Whether the provisions of the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968 are constitutionally valid and compatible with Article 124(4) and (5).
Provisions involved
- Constitution of India — Art. Article 124(4) & 124(5) — Establishment and constitution of Supreme Court / Removal of Judges
- Constitution of India — Art. Article 107 — Provisions as to introduction and passing of Bills and lapse on dissolution
Reasoning
Sui generis nature of judicial removal proceedings
Ray, J. (for the majority) held that proceedings for removal of a judge are not ordinary legislative business governed by Article 107. The Constitution purposely enacted Article 124(5) enabling Parliament to regulate the procedure by law. Once the Speaker admits the motion and appoints an Inquiry Committee under the 1968 Act, the matter passes into the statutory domain.
Doctrine of lapse does not apply to statutory judicial inquiries
The Court held that the motion does not lapse upon dissolution of the Lok Sabha. The Inquiry Committee must complete its investigation and submit its report to the Speaker of the newly constituted Lok Sabha, whereupon the constitutional process continues.
Decision
Writ petition allowed. Held that the motion and Inquiry Committee under the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968 did not lapse upon the dissolution of the 9th Lok Sabha.
Ratio decidendi
A notice of motion for presenting an address to the President for the removal of a Supreme Court or High Court judge admitted by the Speaker under Section 3 of the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968 does not lapse upon the dissolution of the Lok Sabha. The doctrine of lapse governing ordinary legislative bills under Article 107 of the Constitution has no application to the sui generis constitutional proceedings for the removal of a judge under Article 124(4) and (5).
Exam points
- Inapplicability of the doctrine of lapse under Article 107 to judicial removal motions.
- Sui generis constitutional nature of removal proceedings under Article 124(4) and (5).
- Survival of the Judges (Inquiry) Act 1968 statutory committee upon Lok Sabha dissolution.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Article 124, Impeachment, Doctrine of Lapse