Sunil Batra (I) v. Delhi Administration (1978)

Supreme Court of India · (1978) 4 SCC 494 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench

Summary

The 5-Judge Constitution Bench established that prisoners do not shed their fundamental rights upon incarceration. Reading down Section 30(2) of the Prisons Act, 1894, the Court held that solitary confinement and the continuous imposition of bar fetters on death-row prisoners is unconstitutional and violates Articles 14, 19, and 21 unless ordered by a court as a substantive penal sentence.

Facts

  • Sunil Batra, a prisoner sentenced to death by the trial court, was kept in solitary confinement in Tihar Jail awaiting confirmation of his sentence by the High Court.
  • Another prisoner, Charles Sobhraj, was put in continuous iron bar fetters for 24 hours a day inside the prison.
  • Both challenged their harsh custodial treatment under Article 32, alleging violation of Articles 14, 19, and 21.

Issues

  • Whether a prisoner sentenced to death can be kept in solitary confinement under Section 30(2) Prisons Act before his death sentence has become final.
  • Whether putting prisoners in bar fetters continuously without judicial sanction violates Article 21.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Prisoners retain Fundamental Rights

Krishna Iyer, J. and Desai, J. held that conviction for a crime does not reduce the human being into a non-person. Prisoners retain all fundamental rights that are not incompatible with incarceration.

Interpretation of "under sentence of death"

Section 30(2) applies only when the sentence of death has become completely final, conclusive, and indefeasible after dismissal of all appeals and mercy petitions; pre-confirmation solitary confinement is illegal.

Decision

Solitary confinement of death-row prisoners awaiting appeals was declared illegal; bar fetters ordered removed.

Ratio decidendi

Incarceration does not strip a prisoner of Article 21 guarantees; imposing solitary confinement or bar fetters without judicial sanction is an unconstitutional deprivation of personal liberty.

Exam points

  • Held that prisoners retain fundamental rights inside prison walls.
  • Read down Section 30(2) Prisons Act, 1894 regarding solitary confinement.
  • Bar fetters declared inhumane and violative of Article 21.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Article 21, Prisoners Rights, Solitary Confinement

All judgments