Supriyo @ Supriya Chakraborty v. Union of India (Marriage Equality Case) (2023)
Supreme Court of India · (2023) 11 SCC 1 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench
Summary
Constitution Bench decision on same-sex marriage equality. Unanimously recognized that queer persons have a fundamental right against discrimination, right to enter into relationships, and freedom from violence. However, by a 3:2 majority, held that there is no unqualified fundamental right to marry under the Constitution, and that reading gender-neutral language into the Special Marriage Act, 1954 would amount to judicial legislation, leaving statutory recognition of marriage to Parliament.
Facts
- Same-sex couples and queer activists filed writ petitions under Article 32 seeking legal recognition of same-sex marriages under the Special Marriage Act, 1954 (SMA) and Foreign Marriage Act, 1969.
- Petitioners contended that limiting marriage strictly to heterosexual couples (man and woman) violates their fundamental rights to equality (Art. 14), non-discrimination (Art. 15), freedom of expression (Art. 19(1)(a)), and personal dignity, autonomy, and privacy (Art. 21).
- The Union of India opposed the petitions, arguing that defining marriage is a core legislative domain rooted in cultural and religious values and that altering the SMA would destabilize diverse personal and succession statutes.
Issues
- Whether there is a fundamental right to marry under the Constitution of India.
- Whether the provisions of the Special Marriage Act, 1954 are unconstitutional for excluding same-sex couples, or can be read down to be gender-neutral.
- Whether queer couples have the legal right to joint adoption under the Juvenile Justice Act and CARA regulations.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
No fundamental right to marry under Article 21
Bhat, J. for the majority (joined by Kohli and Narasimha, JJ.) held that marriage is a social institution regulated by law. An entitlement to legal recognition of marriage cannot flow automatically from the right to personal liberty. A right to marry is not a fundamental right in itself, although the right of individuals to choose partners and live together is fully protected under Article 21.
Limits of judicial review regarding the Special Marriage Act
The Court held that reading the SMA as gender-neutral would create widespread anomalies across various provisions dealing with alimony, maintenance, domestic violence, and succession that were specifically enacted for the protection of women. It is for Parliament, not courts, to craft a comprehensive legal framework recognizing queer unions.
Decision
Writ petitions dismissed regarding prayer for marriage equality under SMA. The Court recorded the Union Government assurance to set up a high-level Cabinet Committee to explore administrative and financial benefits for same-sex partners.
Ratio decidendi
The Constitution does not expressly or implicitly guarantee a fundamental right to marry. While queer couples have the right to cohabit without state interference and are protected against discrimination under Articles 14 and 15, the creation of a legal status of marriage with attendant civil rights is exclusively within the legislative competence of Parliament and State Legislatures.
Exam points
- Settled that there is no fundamental right to marry under Article 21 of the Indian Constitution.
- Refused to judicially rewrite the Special Marriage Act, 1954 to include same-sex couples.
- Separation of powers benchmark regarding judicial restraint in creating new civil statuses.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Article 21, Article 14, LGBTQIA+, Marriage Equality, Special Marriage Act