Swiss Ribbons Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India (2019)

Supreme Court of India · (2019) 4 SCC 17 · 2-Judge Bench

Summary

Historic decision upholding the complete constitutional validity of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016. Affirmed the intelligible differentia between financial creditors and operational creditors, upheld Section 29A disqualification of defaulting promoters, and held that economic legislation enjoys a high presumption of constitutionality under Article 14.

Facts

  • Various corporate debtors, promoters, and operational creditors filed writ petitions under Article 32 challenging the constitutional validity of several provisions of the IBC, 2016.
  • Key challenges targeted: (1) classification between financial and operational creditors; (2) operational creditors having no voting share in the Committee of Creditors (CoC); (3) bar on defaulting promoters under Section 29A; (4) lack of judicial member parity in NCLAT.

Issues

  • Whether the differential treatment of financial and operational creditors under the IBC violates Article 14.
  • Whether Section 29A IBC barring defaulting promoters from bidding for their own stressed assets is arbitrary or retrospective.
  • Whether Section 12A withdrawal of CIRP with 90% voting share is constitutional.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Intelligible differentia between financial and operational creditors

Nariman, J. held that financial contracts generally involve large sums, are well-documented, and financial creditors possess the expertise to evaluate corporate viability. Operational contracts relate to day-to-day goods/services and are often disputed. The classification under Articles 14 and 19 is fully justified.

Constitutionality of Section 29A

Section 29A was enacted to prevent unscrupulous promoters who ran their companies into insolvency from bidding at heavily discounted haircuts. It serves an overarching public purpose and is not arbitrarily retrospective.

Decision

Writ petitions dismissed. The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, along with Sections 12A, 21, 29A, and 53, upheld as fully constitutional.

Ratio decidendi

The distinction between financial and operational creditors under the IBC is founded on an intelligible differentia with a rational nexus to the objective of timely corporate resolution. Section 29A does not violate Article 14 as it prevents defaulting promoters from regaining corporate control through resolution at public expense.

Exam points

  • Comprehensive constitutional validation of the IBC, 2016.
  • Upheld Section 29A promoter disqualification test.
  • Approved Section 12A CIRP withdrawal threshold of 90% CoC voting share.

Tags: AIBE, Commercial Law, IBC, Section 29A, Article 14, Economic Legislation, Constitutional Law

All judgments