M.C. Mehta v. Union of India (Taj Trapezium Case) (1997)

Supreme Court of India · (1997) 2 SCC 353 · 2-Judge Bench

Summary

The Supreme Court issued sweeping environmental directions to protect the 17th-century world heritage monument Taj Mahal from severe yellowing and chemical degradation caused by sulphur dioxide and industrial acid rain. Applying the Precautionary Principle and Sustainable Development under Article 21, the Court ordered 292 polluting coal- and coke-based industrial units inside the 10,400 sq km Taj Trapezium Zone (TTZ) to either switch over to clean natural gas (CNG/LPG) or relocate outside the zone.

Facts

  • The Taj Mahal, a UNESCO World Heritage monument constructed of pristine white marble, suffered significant discolouration, yellowing, and brown spots caused by toxic emissions from the Mathura Refinery, iron foundries, brick kilns, glass works, and chemical factories in the Agra region.
  • Sulphur dioxide emitted by industries combined with atmospheric moisture to form acid rain ("marble cancer"), corroding the marble structure.
  • Environmentalist advocate M.C. Mehta filed a PIL under Article 32 seeking urgent judicial intervention to save the monument and the ecology of the Taj Trapezium Zone.
  • Expert reports from NEERI (National Environmental Engineering Research Institute) and the Varadarajan Committee confirmed severe air pollution exceeding ambient standards.

Issues

  • Whether commercial industrial activities causing air pollution and acid rain around the Taj Mahal should be shut down or relocated.
  • How the Precautionary Principle and the concept of Sustainable Development apply to the preservation of national monuments under Articles 21, 48A, and 49.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Precautionary Principle and Onus of Proof

Kuldip Singh, J. held that the Precautionary Principle and the Polluter Pays Principle are essential features of Sustainable Development and form part of Indian environmental law under Article 21. When environmental harm threatens irreplaceable heritage, the burden of proof is on the industrialist to demonstrate that their operations are environmentally benign.

Mandatory Gas Switch or Relocation

The Court balanced environmental protection with workers’ rights, directing the 292 industries to apply for gas supply from the Gas Authority of India (GAIL). Industries not switching to natural gas were given a fixed deadline to stop operating with coal/coke and relocate outside the TTZ, with mandatory compensation and continuity of service for affected employees.

Decision

292 industries ordered to switch over to natural gas or relocate outside the TTZ; workers’ employment and terminal benefits protected.

Ratio decidendi

Under the Precautionary Principle and Article 21, commercial industrial units causing atmospheric pollution that threatens national monuments and public health cannot continue using polluting fuels and must either adopt non-polluting fuel or relocate.

Exam points

  • The Taj Trapezium Zone (TTZ) encompasses approximately 10,400 sq km around the Taj Mahal.
  • Recognized "marble cancer" caused by sulphur dioxide emissions and acid rain.
  • Enforced the Precautionary Principle to protect national monuments under Articles 21, 48A, and 49.
  • Directed GAIL to supply natural gas to industries in Agra.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Environment, Taj Mahal, Air Pollution, TTZ, Precautionary Principle

All judgments