Triveniben v. State of Gujarat (1989)
Supreme Court of India · (1989) 1 SCC 678 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench
Summary
Authoritative 5-judge Constitution Bench decision resolving the conflict between Vatheeswaran and Sher Singh. Affirmed that inordinate, unexplained delay in executing a death sentence constitutes a denial of the fundamental right to life under Article 21, entitling the convict to invoke Article 32 for commutation to life imprisonment, but only delay occurring after judicial proceedings have concluded can be taken into account.
Facts
- Conflicting views between 2-judge and 3-judge benches regarding whether prolonged delay on death row automatically invalidates the death sentence led to a reference to a 5-judge Constitution Bench.
- Numerous condemned prisoners whose mercy petitions had languished before the President and Governors for years sought commutation under Article 32.
Issues
- Does inordinate delay in the execution of a death sentence violate Article 21 of the Constitution.
- From what stage can delay be taken into account for commuting a capital sentence.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Post-judicial delay alone is relevant
Oza, J. held that the time taken in the trial, High Court confirmation, Supreme Court appeal, and review petitions cannot be counted as delay because that period was spent in pursuing lawful judicial remedies. The only period of delay that can be considered is the post-judicial phase, i.e., after the sentence has become final and during the pendency of mercy petitions before the President or Governor.
Commutation under Article 32
If there is inordinate, unexplained, and callous delay by the executive in executing the sentence or disposing of mercy petitions, the condemned prisoner is entitled to approach the Supreme Court under Article 32 to have his death sentence commuted to life imprisonment.
Decision
Reference answered. Inordinate, unexplained post-judicial delay held to violate Article 21, justifying commutation of death sentence to imprisonment for life under Article 32.
Ratio decidendi
Under Article 21 of the Constitution, prolonged, inordinate, and unexplained delay by the executive in executing a capital sentence after the conclusion of judicial proceedings entitles the condemned prisoner to approach the court under Article 32/226 to seek commutation of the death sentence to life imprisonment.
Exam points
- Foundational 5-judge Constitution Bench precedent on death penalty delay.
- Only post-judicial delay (mercy petition stage) is counted, not judicial litigation time.
- Ground for commutation of capital sentence under Article 21.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Article 21, Death Penalty, Triveniben, Mercy Petition, Delay