Tukaram v. State of Maharashtra (Mathura Rape Case) (1979)

Supreme Court of India · (1979) 2 SCC 143 · 2-Judge Bench

Summary

Infamous decision reversing the conviction of police constables for the custodial rape of a young tribal girl, Mathura, on the erroneous reasoning that absence of physical injuries inferred passive consent. The widespread outrage sparked an open letter by law professors (Upendra Baxi, Lotika Sarkar et al.) and led to landmark reforms via the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 1983.

Facts

  • Mathura, a young orphaned tribal girl aged between 14 and 16, was summoned to the Desai Ganj police station in Maharashtra.
  • Inside the latrine/compound of the police station in the dead of night, police constables Tukaram and Ganpat subjected her to sexual intercourse.
  • The Sessions Judge acquitted the accused holding Mathura was a "habituated to sexual intercourse" girl who consented.
  • The Bombay High Court reversed and convicted the accused of custodial rape.
  • The Supreme Court reversed the High Court, holding that because there were no marks of physical injury or struggle, Mathura must have passively submitted or consented.

Issues

  • Whether the absence of physical injury on the victim implies voluntary consent under Section 375 IPC.
  • Whether submission under fear and intimidation in police custody constitutes consent.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Flawed conflation of submission with consent

The Supreme Court held that the prosecution failed to prove lack of consent because Mathura showed no marks of physical injury and did not scream. This reasoning ignored the psychological terror and coercive atmosphere of custodial detention.

Decision

Appeal allowed. Accused police constables acquitted on grounds of reasonable doubt regarding consent. (Triggered nationwide legal reform).

Ratio decidendi

The original ruling erroneously equated submission under custodial fear with free consent, establishing a benchmark of physical resistance that was subsequently repealed and reversed by Parliament in the 1983 and 2013 criminal amendments.

Exam points

  • Catalyst for the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 1983.
  • Led to the introduction of Section 114A Indian Evidence Act (presumption of absence of consent in custodial rape).
  • Shifted the focus of rape law from proof of physical resistance to absence of consent.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, IPC, Section 375, Custodial Rape, Evidence Act, Criminal Law Reforms

All judgments