Vidhyadhar v. Manikrao (1999)
Supreme Court of India · (1999) 3 SCC 573 · 2-Judge Bench
Summary
Classic Supreme Court precedent on adverse inference under Section 114 Illustration (g) of the Evidence Act (now Section 119 BSA). Held that where a party to a civil suit refrains from entering the witness box and stating their case on oath or facing cross-examination, a strong adverse inference arises that their pleaded case is untrue.
Facts
- Vidhyadhar filed a suit for redemption of mortgage and recovery of possession of agricultural land transferred to him by a registered sale deed.
- The defendant Manikrao contended that the sale deed was fictitious and without consideration.
- At the trial, Manikrao did not enter the witness box to state his case on oath or offer himself for cross-examination, but merely examined his brother.
- The trial court decreed the suit, but the High Court dismissed it on the ground of non-payment of consideration.
Issues
- What legal consequence follows when a party to a civil suit fails to enter the witness box to substantiate their factual plea.
- Whether adverse inference under Section 114 Illustration (g) arises against a non-testifying party.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Mandatory adverse inference on failure to testify
Saghir Ahmad, J. held: Where a party to the suit does not appear in the witness box and states his own case on oath and does not offer himself to be cross-examined by the other side, a presumption would arise that the case set up by him is not correct.
Application of Section 114 Illustration (g)
The best evidence of personal knowledge lies with the party themselves. Evading the witness box deprives the opposite party of the statutory right to cross-examine on contentious facts, triggering an adverse presumption under Section 114 Illustration (g).
Decision
Appeal allowed. High Court judgment set aside; trial court decree in favor of plaintiff restored.
Ratio decidendi
Where a party to a civil dispute does not enter the witness box to substantiate facts within their personal knowledge on oath and submit to cross-examination, the court is entitled to draw an adverse inference under Section 114 Illustration (g) of the Evidence Act that their pleaded version is false.
Exam points
- Core precedent for Section 114 Illustration (g) Evidence Act (Section 119 BSA).
- Failure to enter witness box leads to adverse inference.
- Examined in AIBE and Judiciary civil trial practice papers.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Evidence, Section 114, BSA 119, CPC, Adverse Inference