Vineeta Sharma v. Rakesh Sharma (2020)

Supreme Court of India · (2020) 9 SCC 1 · 3-Judge Bench

Summary

Historic 3-judge bench decision resolving conflicting precedents on the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005. Held that daughters possess coparcenary rights under amended Section 6 by birth in their own right in the same manner as sons. The coparcenary right is retroactive; the living status of the coparcener father on September 9, 2005 is immaterial.

Facts

  • Following the enactment of the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005, which amended Section 6 to confer coparcenary status on daughters by birth, conflicting rulings emerged across high courts and two-judge benches of the Supreme Court.
  • In Prakash v. Phulavati (2016), the Supreme Court held that the amended Section 6 applied prospectively and required both the coparcener father and daughter to be alive on September 9, 2005.
  • In Danamma v. Amar (2018), another two-judge bench took the contrary view that daughters were entitled to coparcenary property even where the father had passed away before 2005.
  • A reference was made to a 3-judge bench in Vineeta Sharma to authoritatively interpret the temporal operation of Section 6.

Issues

  • Whether the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005 has retroactive effect conferring coparcenary rights on daughters born prior to September 9, 2005.
  • Whether the living status of the father coparcener on September 9, 2005 is a condition precedent for a daughter to claim coparcenary rights.
  • What is the legal effect of an unregistered family settlement or oral partition effected prior to December 20, 2004.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Coparcenary rights acquired by birth (unobstructed heritage)

Arun Mishra, J. explained that coparcenary rights under Section 6 are acquired by birth (Apratibandha Daya / unobstructed heritage) and not upon the death of the father (Sapratibandha Daya / obstructed heritage). Since the right is by birth, the requirement that the father must be alive on 09.09.2005 is alien to Section 6.

Retroactive application of Section 6 amendment

The amendment operates retroactively because it applies from the date of the amendment while looking back to the antecedent event of birth. The fiction of notional partition under the unamended Act did not sever the coparcenary so as to bar daughters where no registered partition deed or final decree occurred prior to 20.12.2004.

Decision

Reference answered in favour of coparcenary rights of daughters. Overruled Prakash v. Phulavati. The Supreme Court held that Section 6 confers coparcenary rights on daughters by birth. It is an unobstructed heritage; the father coparcener need not have been alive on September 9, 2005.

Ratio decidendi

The provisions contained in substituted Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 confer the status of coparcener on the daughter born before or after the amendment in the same manner as a son with the same rights and liabilities. Coparcenary rights are acquired by birth (unobstructed heritage) and not by survivorship or succession upon the death of the father. Therefore, the requirement that the father must be alive on the date of amendment (09.09.2005) is alien to Section 6.

Exam points

  • Overruled Prakash v. Phulavati (2016) regarding father survival on 09.09.2005.
  • Held coparcenary is an unobstructed heritage acquired by birth under Section 6(1).
  • Clarified the high evidentiary threshold for proving oral partitions prior to 20.12.2004.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Family Law, HSA, Coparcenary, Gender Equality, Section 6

All judgments