Waman Rao v. Union of India (1981)

Supreme Court of India · (1981) 2 SCC 362 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench

Summary

The Constitution Bench drew a clear demarcation line for Ninth Schedule immunity: all amendments and additions to the Ninth Schedule made prior to 24 April 1973 (the date of Kesavananda Bharati) are valid and immune from challenge, whereas all additions made on or after 24 April 1973 are open to challenge on the ground of violating the basic structure.

Facts

  • The Maharashtra Agricultural Lands (Ceiling on Holdings) Act, 1961 was amended in 1975 to lower land ceiling limits and placed into the Ninth Schedule by the 40th Constitutional Amendment.
  • Landowners challenged the validity of Articles 31A, 31B, and 31C as well as the 40th Amendment, arguing that immunizing laws from Part III violates the basic structure.

Issues

  • Whether Article 31A, 31B, and the unamended Article 31C violate the basic structure of the Constitution.
  • Whether laws inserted into the Ninth Schedule after 24 April 1973 are open to challenge on basic structure grounds.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Validity of Articles 31A and 31B

The Court held that Articles 31A and 31B were enacted to eliminate feudal zamindari systems and advance agrarian justice, and do not damage the basic structure.

The 24 April 1973 demarcation line

Since Kesavananda Bharati propounded the basic structure doctrine on 24 April 1973, certainty and stability of laws demand prospective application: pre-1973 additions are protected, but post-1973 additions can be tested against the basic structure.

Decision

Articles 31A and 31B were upheld; Ninth Schedule additions post-24 April 1973 were declared subject to basic structure review.

Ratio decidendi

The basic structure doctrine applies prospectively from 24 April 1973 to test all subsequent constitutional amendments adding enactments to the Ninth Schedule.

Exam points

  • Established 24 April 1973 as the watershed date for Ninth Schedule immunity.
  • Laws added to Ninth Schedule prior to 24 April 1973 are completely immune.
  • Laws added on or after 24 April 1973 are subject to basic structure review.
  • Approved in unanimous 9-Judge bench ruling in I.R. Coelho (2007).

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Ninth Schedule, Basic Structure, Cut-off Date

All judgments