Arrest & Rights of Arrested

Criminal Procedure (BNSS / CrPC)

Arrest without warrant is BNSS s. 35 (old CrPC 41, with the 41A notice folded in). Arrest is an exception, not the default, for offences punishable up to seven years. Handcuffing of specified serious offenders is s. 43(3).

Study notes

Topic at a glance

Arrest is a deprivation of personal liberty. Article 22 and Article 21 sit behind every clause. Joginder Kumar and Arnesh Kumar still teach necessity; the BNSS writes a large part of that discipline into s. 35.

When police may arrest without warrant — s. 35

Cognizable offence in the officer’s presence, or reasonable complaint / credible information / reasonable suspicion of a cognizable offence.

For offences punishable with imprisonment of less than seven years, or which may extend to seven years, arrest is permitted only if it is necessary for the statutory reasons (prevent further offence, proper investigation, prevent tampering or threatening witnesses, presence in court) and reasons must be recorded.

s. 35(3): where arrest is not required, the officer shall issue a notice to appear. Compliance with the notice generally protects against arrest unless reasons to arrest are recorded. This is the old 41A idea, now inside s. 35.

How arrest is made — s. 43

Touch or confinement, unless submission to custody. A woman’s submission is presumed on oral intimation; a male officer is not to touch her unless circumstances require.

s. 43(3) permits handcuffs, having regard to nature and gravity, for habitual/repeat offenders, escapees, and specified grave offences (organised crime, terrorist act, drugs, illegal arms, murder, rape, acid attack, counterfeiting, trafficking, sexual offence against children, offence against the State).

s. 43(5): no woman after sunset and before sunrise save exceptional circumstances, with a woman officer’s written report and prior permission of a Magistrate of the first class.

Duties and rights

s. 36 — identification of the officer, arrest memo, attestation (D.K. Basu now largely statutory).

Informing grounds and the right to bail — s. 47 family; confirm the exact clauses in the Bare Act.

Production before a Magistrate — the 24-hour rule continues (historically CrPC 57/167; current production/remand cluster includes s. 58 and s. 187). Do not detain as a punishment.

Remand — s. 187

Police custody is not a free 15-day block that must be the first 15 days. The BNSS allows the 15 days of police custody to be sought in parts within the outer investigation-custody period. Confirm the exact inner limits in the Bare Act before arguing detention limits.

Current-law position

Cite s. 35, not CrPC 41, for arrests on or after 1 July 2024. Arnesh Kumar is still the case you name for the seven-year necessity rule.

Educational note

This page replaces a mis-filed cognizance dump that previously lived under “arrest”. Cognizance is s. 210 on the Charge & Trial topic.

Statutory provisions

  • Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 — s. s. 35 — When police may arrest without warrant
  • Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 — s. s. 36 — Procedure of arrest and duties of officer making arrest
  • Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 — s. s. 43 — Arrest how made
  • Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 — s. s. 187 — Procedure when investigation cannot be completed in twenty-four hours

Illustrations

Example 1 — simple

A is accused of a three-year cognizable offence and is cooperating. s. 35(3) points to a notice of appearance, not an automatic lock-up.

Example 2 — legal

A woman accused of theft at 10 p.m. cannot be arrested after sunset except in the s. 43(5) exceptional path (woman officer, written report, prior Magistrate permission).

Problem questions

Examination hypothetical

Police arrest A at 8 p.m. for a four-year cognizable offence, do not record reasons, do not issue a s. 35(3) notice, and handcuff him though he has no previous conviction and the offence is not in the s. 43(3) list.

How many BNSS rules are broken?

s. 35 necessity + recorded reasons + notice; Arnesh Kumar; s. 43(3) handcuffs; Art 21/22.

For a sub-seven-year offence, arrest requires recorded necessity. The notice route was ignored. Handcuffs are not a default; s. 43(3) is a specified-offence power. The arrest is illegal in discipline even if the officer had power in the abstract. The Court may still have to deal with the fact of custody, but the illegality goes to compensation, disciplinary action, and often to bail.

s. 35 and s. 43(3) are both breached. Educational hypothetical.

Distinctions

Arrest and notice to appear

  • Custody: Yes / No, if the person complies
  • When: Necessity reasons exist and are recorded (especially ≤7 years) / Arrest is not required
  • CrPC history: s. 41 / s. 41A, now folded into s. 35
  • Arrest under s. 35(1)
  • Notice under s. 35(3)

Common misconceptions

Every cognizable offence requires arrest.

For offences up to seven years, arrest is necessity-based. Notice is the default when arrest is not required.

Handcuffing is routine.

s. 43(3) is limited to the listed categories and to gravity. It is not a general power.

This topic is cognizance under s. 210.

Cognizance is Charge & Trial. Arrest is ss. 35–43 and production/remand.

Leading cases

  • Joginder Kumar v. State of U.P. (1994), (1994) 4 SCC 260 — Arrest is not mandatory merely because it is lawful. There must be a justification.
  • D.K. Basu v. State of W.B. (1997), (1997) 1 SCC 416 — Arrest-memo and allied safeguards. Largely statutory now in s. 36.
  • Arnesh Kumar v. State of Bihar (2014), (2014) 8 SCC 273 — For offences punishable with up to seven years, police must record satisfaction of the necessity conditions before arrest; Magistrates must not authorise detention mechanically.

Questions & answers

Which BNSS section governs arrest without warrant?

s. 35 (historically CrPC 41, with 41A notice folded into s. 35(3)).

Which case insisted on recorded reasons before arrest in offences up to seven years?

Arnesh Kumar v. State of Bihar (2014). The BNSS now writes that discipline into s. 35.

Bare Act pointers

  • BNSS s. 35
  • s. 36
  • s. 43
  • s. 47
  • s. 58
  • s. 187
  • CrPC 41/41A (historical)

Exam tips

  • Do not write CrPC 41 as the current section.
  • If the facts are a woman at night, s. 43(5) is a free mark.

Answer skeleton

  • Introduction — liberty and necessity.
  • s. 35.
  • Notice s. 35(3).
  • s. 43 special rules.
  • Cases.
  • Conclusion.

Revision points

  • s. 35 = old 41 + 41A notice.
  • ≤7 years: arrest only if necessary; record reasons.
  • Handcuffs: s. 43(3) listed offences, not routine.
  • Arnesh Kumar still cited.

Judgments on this provision

Related topics