Relevancy of Facts
Evidence may be given only of facts in issue and of facts declared relevant. BSA Chapter II (ss. 3–50). The gateway is s. 3. Same-transaction facts are s. 4 ([[REF:DOCTRINE:EVIDENCE-LAW:RES-GESTAE|res gestae]]). Current law from 1 July 2024; IEA numbers are historical concordance only.
Study notes
Topic at a glance
Relevancy is the first filter. Admissibility is the second. A fact can be relevant and still excluded (privilege, hearsay limits, improperly obtained electronic records). Do not collapse the two.
What does the law say?
BSA s. 3: evidence may be given in any suit or proceeding of the existence or non-existence of every fact in issue and of such other facts as are declared relevant in the Adhiniyam, and of no others.
Why does relevancy exist?
Courts would drown if every surrounding circumstance came in. Relevancy is a statutory catalogue, not a free “common-sense” discretion. The catalogue (occasion, cause, effect, motive, preparation, conduct, conspiracy, state of mind, admissions, dying declarations, judgments, opinions, character) is Chapter II.
Essential elements
1. Identify the fact in issue (the fact that the substantive law makes decisive).
2. Ask whether the tendered fact is that fact, or a fact the BSA declares relevant.
3. If it is relevant, ask whether any later chapter excludes it (proof, privilege, electronic certificate, estoppel).
How it operates
Start with the charge or the plaint. List facts in issue. Then slot the witness’s story into a section: s. 4 (same transaction), s. 6 (motive/preparation/conduct), s. 8 (conspiracy), ss. 15–25 (admissions/confessions), s. 26 (statements of persons who cannot be called). If you cannot name a section, it is probably irrelevant.
Current-law position
BSA ss. 3–50 from 1 July 2024. IEA 5–55 is the historical map. Res gestae teaching case law on IEA 6 still explains the idea of “transaction”, but the current cite is BSA s. 4.
Educational note
Do not treat every interesting fact as relevant. Name the section.
Statutory provisions
- Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 — s. s. 3 — Evidence may be given of facts in issue and relevant facts
- Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 — s. s. 4 — Relevancy of facts forming part of same transaction
- Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 — s. s. 6 — Motive, preparation and previous or subsequent conduct
Illustrations
Example 1 — simple
In a stabbing trial the fact in issue is who stabbed. That the accused bought a knife an hour earlier is preparation (s. 6). That a stranger once stole mangoes from the same village is irrelevant.
Example 2 — legal
A bystander’s shout “he has a gun” at the moment of firing may be part of the same transaction (s. 4). The bystander’s statement to police two days later is not s. 4; it must find another route or stay out.
Problem questions
Examination hypothetical
Immediately after a blast, a dying shopkeeper gasps to a customer, “Raju planted it.” Two days later the customer tells the investigating officer the same words.
Is the gasp relevant? Is the later police statement relevant as res gestae?
BSA s. 4 (same transaction); s. 26 family for statements of persons who cannot be called (dying declaration teaching); res gestae is not a hearsay free-for-all.
The gasp, if contemporaneous and part of the event, is a s. 4 fact and may also be a s. 26 statement. The customer’s police statement two days later is a later narrative, not the transaction. It may be used to corroborate the customer as a witness, but it is not res gestae.
Gasp: likely relevant. Delayed police version: not s. 4. Educational hypothetical.
Distinctions
Relevancy and admissibility
- Question: Does the BSA declare this fact relevant? / May it be proved in the manner proposed?
- Example: Motive under s. 6 / Electronic chat without s. 63 certificate
- Relevancy (ss. 3–50)
- Admissibility (later chapters)
Common misconceptions
Everything logically connected is relevant.
Only facts the BSA declares relevant. Logic is not a section.
IEA 6 is the current res gestae section.
Current law is BSA s. 4. IEA 6 is concordance.
Leading cases
- Ratten v. The Queen (1972), [1972] AC 378 — A contemporaneous call can be part of the event rather than a later narrative. Teaching authority on spontaneity; apply the BSA “transaction” test, do not treat Privy Council facts as Indian statute.
- Gentela Vijayavardhan Rao v. State of A.P. (1996), (1996) 6 SCC 241 — Statements must be reasonably contemporaneous with the transaction to come in as res gestae under the then IEA s. 6.
Questions & answers
What is the gateway provision for relevancy under the BSA?
Section 3 — evidence of facts in issue and of facts declared relevant, and of no others.
Which BSA section covers facts forming part of the same transaction?
Section 4 (historically IEA s. 6).
Bare Act pointers
- BSA ss. 3–50
- s. 4
- s. 6
- IEA 5–6 (historical)
Exam tips
- Write BSA numbers first, IEA in brackets as historical.
- Never use “res gestae” without “same transaction”.
Answer skeleton
- Introduction — s. 3 gateway.
- Fact in issue / relevant fact.
- Principal heads of Chapter II with one illustration each for s. 4 and s. 6.
- Relevancy ≠ admissibility.
- Current BSA numbering.
- Conclusion.
Revision points
- s. 3 gateway; “and of no others”.
- s. 4 same transaction (old IEA 6).
- s. 6 motive, preparation, conduct (old IEA 8).
- Relevant facts can still be inadmissible.