Section 162 — Refreshing memory
Evidence (BSA / Evidence Act) · s. 162 · Examination of witnesses
BSA s. 162 permits a witness, while under examination, to refresh memory from qualifying writings made by the witness at or sufficiently soon after the transaction; it also permits reference to another person's writing if the witness read it while the transaction was fresh and knew it to be correct. It includes a controlled route for copies and permits experts to use professional treatises.
Study notes
CURRENT LAW
Section 162 is in Chapter X, Examination of Witnesses. It is a witness-management and memory rule, not a substitute for the rules governing admissibility of the underlying document or the proof of the facts recorded. The section should be read with ss. 163 and 164.
WHEN MEMORY MAY BE REFRESHED
Under s. 162(1), the witness may refer during examination to a writing made by the witness at the time of the transaction or so soon afterwards that the Court considers it likely that the transaction was then fresh in the witness's memory. The proviso permits reference to a writing made by another person if the witness read it within that relevant period and knew it to be correct when reading it.
COPIES AND EXPERTS
Under s. 162(2), the witness may, with Court permission, refer to a copy where the Court is satisfied there is sufficient reason for non-production of the original. The further proviso recognises an expert's ability to refresh memory from professional treatises. The procedural permission and reliability conditions should be recorded rather than assumed.
REFRESHING MEMORY IS NOT AUTOMATIC SUBSTANTIVE PROOF
The writing is a memory aid. Section 163 separately governs testimony to facts stated in a qualifying document when the witness has no specific recollection but is sure the facts were correctly recorded. Section 164 protects the adverse party's right to production and cross-examination of writings used to refresh memory.
DIGITAL RECORDS
A witness may encounter electronic documents or records while refreshing memory. The Court should distinguish the witness's use of a record to revive recollection from tendering the electronic record itself as substantive documentary evidence. If the latter is tendered, apply the relevant electronic-record provisions, including s. 63 where applicable.
TRANSITION
Use BSA numbering for current proceedings and consult s. 170 for saved proceedings under the former Evidence Act.
Qualifying Writing and Timing
The writing must have been made by the witness at the time of the transaction or sufficiently soon afterwards that the Court considers the transaction likely to have been fresh in memory.
A writing by another person can qualify if the witness read it within the relevant period and knew it to be correct when reading it.
The statutory timing and knowledge requirements should be proved from the circumstances rather than assumed.
Copies and Expert Treatises
A copy may be used with Court permission when the Court is satisfied there is sufficient reason for non-production of the original.
Experts may refresh memory by reference to professional treatises under the statutory proviso.
The Court should distinguish memory refreshment from admission of the treatise or copy as independent substantive evidence.
Witness Testimony and Section 163
Refreshing memory helps the witness recall; it does not itself transform the writing into the witness's testimony.
Section 163 provides a distinct route where a witness can testify to facts in a qualifying document despite lacking specific recollection, provided the witness is sure the facts were correctly recorded.
Always identify which route is being invoked.
Adverse Party and Digital Material
Section 164 requires writings referred to under the preceding memory provisions to be produced and shown to the adverse party if required, with a corresponding opportunity for cross-examination.
Where a digital record is used, distinguish the witness's memory aid from tender of the electronic record as evidence.
If the digital record itself is tendered, apply the applicable electronic-record admissibility route independently.
Courtroom Practice and Error Control
Record the foundation: when the writing was made, who made it, when the witness read it, why the witness knew it to be correct, and why a copy is being used if relevant.
Do not suggest that merely showing a document to a witness proves every fact contained in it.
Use the current BSA sections and historical Evidence Act numbering only as concordance or under the savings provision.
Statutory provisions
- Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 — s. s. 162 — Refreshing memory
- Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 — s. s. 163 — Testimony to facts stated in document mentioned in section 162
- Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 — s. s. 164 — Right of adverse party as to writing used to refresh memory
- Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 — s. s. 63 — Admissibility of electronic records
- Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 — s. s. 170 — Repeal and savings
Illustrations
Contemporaneous diary
A witness made a diary entry immediately after a transaction and now cannot recall every detail. During examination the witness may use the qualifying entry to refresh memory, subject to the statutory foundation and the adverse party's rights.
Copy with Court permission
The original writing is unavailable and a party asks the witness to use a copy. The witness cannot assume the copy is permitted; the Court must be satisfied that there is sufficient reason for non-production of the original and grant the required permission.
Problem questions
Chamber Problem: Digital Log Used to Refresh Memory
A technical witness cannot recall the exact sequence of events but reviewed a system log shortly after the incident and knew it to be accurate. At trial the witness uses a copy of the log; the opposing party demands production and cross-examination.
Can the witness use the record to refresh memory and what additional safeguards apply?
BSA ss. 162–164 and s. 63 if the electronic record itself is tendered as substantive evidence.
Establish when the record was made or read, who created it, why the witness knew it to be correct, and why the copy is used. Obtain Court permission where s. 162(2) requires it. If the record itself is offered as substantive evidence, separately satisfy the electronic-record rules. Produce the writing to the adverse party when required.
The memory-refresh route and substantive admission of the electronic record are distinct. The former may assist testimony without automatically proving every recorded fact.
Distinctions
Sections 162–164
- Function: Refresh the witness's memory using qualifying writings / s. 163 permits testimony to facts correctly recorded; s. 164 gives the adverse party production and cross-examination rights
- Witness state: Witness uses writing to revive recollection / s. 163 addresses lack of specific recollection but confidence in accurate recording
- Control: Timing, authorship, knowledge and Court permission for copies / Production and adversarial testing of the writing
- s. 162
- ss. 163–164
Common misconceptions
Any document can be used to refresh memory.
The statutory timing, authorship/reading and knowledge requirements must be satisfied.
Refreshing memory makes the document substantive proof automatically.
Memory refreshment is distinct from tendering the document as independent evidence.
The opposing party has no right to see the writing.
Section 164 gives the adverse party a right to production and cross-examination when its conditions are met.
Leading cases
- Browne v. Dunn (1893), (1893) 6 R 67 — The Court treated the failure to put the challenge as significant to the fairness of the evidentiary process.
Questions & answers
Prepare a brief on BSA s. 162.
ISSUE: Identify the writing and the witness's memory problem. RULE: Apply s. 162(1) timing/authorship/knowledge conditions and s. 162(2) copy/expert provisions. APPLICATION: establish the foundation and distinguish memory refreshment from substantive proof. ADVERSE PARTY: apply s. 164. DIGITAL: separately apply s. 63 if the record itself is tendered.
Draft submissions on BSA s. 162.
I. WITNESS AND TRANSACTION
II. WRITING AND STATUTORY FOUNDATION
III. TIMING / AUTHENTICITY / KNOWLEDGE
IV. COPY OR EXPERT TREATISE ISSUE
V. S. 163 AND S. 164 CONSEQUENCES
VI. DIGITAL RECORD FOUNDATION WHERE APPLICABLE
VII. ORDER SOUGHT
Bare Act pointers
- BSA s. 162(1)
- BSA s. 162(2)
- BSA ss. 163–164
- BSA s. 63 where an electronic record is separately tendered
- BSA s. 170
Exam tips
- Refreshing memory is a witness rule, not automatic proof of the document.
- Remember the timing and knowledge requirements.
- Copies require Court permission on the statutory conditions.
- The adverse party's inspection and cross-examination rights matter.
Revision points
- s. 162 = refreshing memory.
- s. 163 = testimony to correctly recorded facts despite lack of specific recollection.
- s. 164 = adverse party's production/cross-examination right.
- Electronic-record admissibility remains a separate issue.