Witnesses & Examination
Who may testify, privileges, accomplices and number of witnesses are BSA ss. 124–139. How they are examined — examination-in-chief, cross, re-examination, leading questions — is ss. 140–168.
Study notes
Topic at a glance
Competency is Chapter IX. Procedure of examination is Chapter X. Students mix them. A child may be competent (s. 124) and still be destroyed in cross-examination (ss. 142–149).
Who may testify
s. 124 — all persons are competent unless the Court considers they cannot understand questions or give rational answers (extreme youth, extreme old age, disease). s. 125 — a witness unable to communicate verbally may testify by writing or signs. Husband and wife, judges, official and professional communications occupy ss. 126–134.
Privileges (do not dump)
Marriage communications (s. 128), affairs of State (s. 129), official communications (s. 130), professional communications with legal advisers (s. 132) — each has statutory limits. An accomplice is competent (s. 138); as a matter of prudence his evidence is corroborated. s. 139 — no particular number of witnesses is required.
Examination
s. 142 — examination-in-chief, cross-examination, re-examination. s. 146 — leading questions. Chief: no leading on disputed matters. Cross: leading allowed. s. 148 — previous statements in writing. Hostile witness teaching lives in the examination chapter — confirm the exact BSA section in the Bare Act before numbering it (historically IEA 154).
Why it exists
Trials are oral. The Adhiniyam decides who may speak, what they may refuse to speak, and how the opponent may test them. Without cross-examination, chief is a speech.
Current-law position
BSA ss. 124–168 from 1 July 2024. IEA 118–166 is historical concordance. Do not assume every IEA number plus two equals the BSA number — map each privilege separately.
Educational note
needs-review of the exact BSA section for “hostile witness” before relying on that evidentiary device in written submissions.
Statutory provisions
- Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 — s. s. 124 — Who may testify
- Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 — s. s. 132 — Professional communications
- Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 — s. s. 138 — Accomplice
- Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 — s. s. 142 — Examination of witnesses
- Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 — s. s. 146 — Leading questions
Illustrations
Example 1 — simple
A seven-year-old who understands questions and can answer rationally is competent under s. 124. There is no statutory minimum age.
Example 2 — legal
Counsel in chief asks “the accused stabbed the deceased with this knife, didn’t he?” That is a leading question on a disputed fact and is improper in chief (s. 146). The same question in cross is proper.
Problem questions
Examination hypothetical
The only eyewitness is an accomplice who turns approver. He is coherent. There is no independent corroboration of the identity of the accused.
Can a conviction rest on him?
s. 124 competency; s. 138 accomplice; s. 139 number of witnesses; prudence of corroboration.
He is competent. s. 139 says no particular number is required. Indian prudence, however, is that an accomplice should be corroborated in material particulars, especially identity. A conviction on a wholly uncorroborated approver is legally possible but practically unsafe; the student should say so.
Admissible and competent; unsafe to convict without corroboration of identity. Educational hypothetical.
Distinctions
Competency and examination
- Question: May this person be a witness? / How is this witness questioned?
- Typical issues: Child, privilege, accomplice / Leading questions, cross, previous statements
- Chapter IX (ss. 124–139)
- Chapter X (ss. 140–168)
Common misconceptions
A child below 12 cannot testify.
s. 124 has no age cut-off. The test is understanding and rational answers.
An accomplice is incompetent.
s. 138: an accomplice is a competent witness. Corroboration is prudence, not a statutory ban.
Leading cases
- Rameshwar v. State of Rajasthan (1952), AIR 1952 SC 54 — A child witness may be competent if the Court is satisfied on understanding; corroboration of a child is a rule of prudence.
- Ravinder Singh v. State of Haryana (1975), (1975) 3 SCC 742 — An approver’s evidence is admissible but is to be corroborated in material particulars.
Questions & answers
Who may testify under BSA s. 124?
All persons, unless the Court considers they cannot understand the questions or give rational answers.
When are leading questions allowed?
As a rule in cross-examination; not in examination-in-chief on disputed matters (s. 146).
Bare Act pointers
- BSA ss. 124–139
- ss. 140–168
- s. 124
- s. 138
- s. 146
Exam tips
- Do not write a minimum age for child witnesses.
- If the question is “hostile witness”, look up the BSA section in the Bare Act rather than guessing IEA 154 + offset.
Answer skeleton
- Introduction — competency vs examination.
- s. 124.
- Accomplice s. 138.
- Leading questions s. 146.
- Illustration.
- Conclusion.
Revision points
- s. 124 all persons unless incapable of rational answers.
- s. 138 accomplice competent; corroboration is prudence.
- s. 139 no fixed number.
- s. 146 leading questions in cross, not in chief on disputed facts.