Article 12 — Definition
Constitutional Law · Art 12 · Foundation
Study notes
## 1. Constitutional Text & Structural Role of Article 12
Article 12 of the Constitution of India provides:
> *"In this Part, unless the context otherwise requires, 'the State' includes the Government and Parliament of India and the Government and the Legislature of each of the States and all local or other authorities within the territory of India or under the control of the Government of India."*
### The Gatekeeper of Fundamental Rights
Fundamental Rights in Part III (Articles 12–35) are essentially constitutional guarantees enforceable against the **State**. With limited exceptions where rights operate against private individuals (e.g., Article 17 abolishing untouchability, Article 23 prohibiting human trafficking and forced labour, Article 24 prohibiting child labour), an aggrieved person seeking judicial enforcement of a Fundamental Right under Article 32 or Article 226 must establish that the respondent entity is the **"State"** within the meaning of Article 12.
---
## 2. Statutory Components of Article 12
Article 12 enumerates four institutional categories:
1. **The Government and Parliament of India:** The Union Executive (President, Ministries, Departments) and the Union Legislature (Lok Sabha, Rajya Sabha).
2. **The Government and the Legislature of each State:** The State Executive (Governor, Departments) and the State Legislature (Vidhan Sabha, Vidhan Parishad).
3. **Local Authorities:** Defined under Section 3(31) of the General Clauses Act, 1897 as Municipal Corporations, Municipalities, Zilla Parishads, Gram Panchayats, Port Trusts, and Improvement Trusts exercising local self-government, statutory taxation, or municipal regulatory powers (*Union of India v. R.C. Jain*, 1981).
4. **"Other Authorities":** The most litigated and dynamic constitutional phrase.
---
## 3. The Judicial Evolution of "Other Authorities"
### A. The Restrictive Ejusdem Generis Phase
In *University of Madras v. Shantha Bai* (AIR 1954 Mad 67), the Madras High Court held that "other authorities" must be construed *ejusdem generis* with the preceding bodies—meaning authorities exercising sovereign or governmental functions. Universities were held not to be State.
### B. The Rejection of Ejusdem Generis: *R.S.E.B. v. Mohan Lal* (AIR 1967 SC 1857)
A 5-judge Constitution Bench overruled *Shantha Bai*. The Supreme Court held that the *ejusdem generis* rule had no application because the preceding bodies in Article 12 did not belong to a single homogeneous genus.
- The Court ruled that "other authorities" includes **any authority created by a statute or the Constitution and conferred with powers by law**, regardless of whether it exercises commercial or sovereign functions. The Rajasthan State Electricity Board was held to be State.
### C. The Instrumentality or Agency Test: *Sukhdev Singh* and *R.D. Shetty*
- In *Sukhdev Singh v. Bhagatram* (1975) 1 SCC 421, Justice K.K. Mathew delivered a pathbreaking concurring opinion, asking: Why should the state be permitted to evade Fundamental Rights simply by operating behind the corporate veil of statutory corporations (LIC, ONGC, IFC)?
- In *Ramana Dayaram Shetty v. International Airport Authority of India (IAAI)* (1979) 3 SCC 489, Justice P.N. Bhagwati formulated the **Instrumentality or Agency Test**: Where a corporation is an instrumentality or agency of the Government, it falls within Article 12, regardless of whether it is created by a statute or registered under the Companies Act.
### D. The Crystallization: *Ajay Hasia v. Khalid Mujib Sehravardi* (1981) 1 SCC 722
A 5-judge Constitution Bench consolidated the *R.D. Shetty* principles into a definitive **6-factor test** to determine whether a registered society (Regional Engineering College, Srinagar) is an instrumentality of the State:
1. **Capital Structure:** If the entire share capital of the corporation is held by the Government, it goes a long way towards indicating that it is an instrumentality of the State.
2. **Financial Assistance:** Where the financial assistance of the State is so large as to meet almost the entire expenditure of the corporation.
3. **Monopoly Status:** Whether the corporation enjoys monopoly status which is State-conferred or State-protected.
4. **State Control:** Deep and pervasive State control over the management and policies of the corporation.
5. **Public Function:** If the functions of the corporation are of public importance and closely related to governmental functions.
6. **Departmental Transfer:** If a department of Government is transferred to a corporation, it is a strong factor supporting instrumentality.
*Ajay Hasia* emphasized that the form of the entity (statutory corporation, registered company under Companies Act, or society under Societies Registration Act) is irrelevant. What matters is the **substance of State control**.
### E. The Modern Benchmark: *Pradeep Kumar Biswas v. Indian Institute of Chemical Biology* (2002) 5 SCC 111
A 7-judge Constitution Bench re-examined whether the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) was "State", overruling the 1975 decision in *Sabhajit Tewary*.
- Chief Justice Ruma Pal synthesized the doctrine into the modern standard:
> *"The question in each case would be whether in the light of the cumulative facts as established, the body is financially, functionally and administratively dominated by or under the pervasive control of the Government. Such control must be particular to the body in question and must be pervasive. If this is found, the body is a State within Article 12."*
- **Regulatory Control vs Pervasive Control:** Mere regulatory control under general statutes (such as the Companies Act or SEBI regulations) does not make a private entity "State". The control must be deep, pervasive, and particularized.
---
## 4. Specific Institutional Applications
### A. The Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI): *Zee Telefilms Ltd. v. Union of India* (2005)
A 5-judge Constitution Bench held by a 3:2 majority that the BCCI is **not "State" under Article 12**:
- BCCI is not created by statute, does not receive government finances, holds no state-protected monopoly, and the government has no deep or pervasive control over its management.
- **Article 226 Amenability:** However, in *BCCI v. Cricket Association of Bihar* (2015), the Court held that because BCCI discharges a public function (selecting national teams and regulating a public sport), it is amenable to writ review under Article 226 for breach of public duties and fairness, even though it is not "State" under Article 12.
### B. Is the Judiciary "The State" under Article 12?
- **Administrative Functions:** When High Courts or the Supreme Court act in an administrative capacity (e.g., framing rules, recruiting judicial staff under Arts 146/229), they are indisputably "the State" and must adhere to Articles 14, 15, and 16.
- **Judicial Functions:** In its judicial capacity, a judicial order passed by a competent court cannot be challenged by an Article 32 writ petition on the ground that it violates Fundamental Rights (*Naresh Shridhar Mirajkar v. State of Maharashtra*, 1967; *Prem Chand Garg*, 1963).
- **Remedy against Judicial Errors:** The remedy against a judicial order lies in appeals, review petitions under Article 137, or a **Curative Petition** under Article 142 (*Rupa Ashok Hurra v. Ashok Hurra*, 2002), not a writ under Article 32 alleging violation of Part III.
Constitutional Gatekeeper: Article 12 Enumeration
Fundamental Rights are primarily enforceable against the State. Article 12 defines State for Part III.
Four categories: Union Government & Parliament, State Government & Legislature, Local Authorities (General Clauses Act s. 3(31)), and Other Authorities.
The Instrumentality or Agency Test (R.D. Shetty to Ajay Hasia)
Rejection of ejusdem generis: RSEB v. Mohan Lal included all statutory authorities.
Ajay Hasia formulated the 6-factor test: capital shareholding, financial aid, monopoly status, deep and pervasive state control, public functions, and department transfer.
The corporate veil of companies and societies will be pierced to enforce Part III.
The Modern Benchmark: Pradeep Kumar Biswas and Private Bodies
Pradeep Kumar Biswas (7-judge bench) laid down the modern test: financial, functional, and administrative domination by the State.
Distinction between deep/pervasive control and mere statutory regulation (Zee Telefilms).
Amenability of non-State public bodies under Article 226 vs Article 12.
The Judiciary as "State": Administrative vs Judicial Functions
Judiciary is State when performing administrative and rule-making duties.
Judicial determinations are not amenable to Article 32 writs (Naresh Mirajkar); remedy lies in appeal, review, or curative petitions (Rupa Ashok Hurra).
Statutory provisions
- Constitution of India — Art. Article 12 — Definition of State for Part III
- Constitution of India — Art. Article 13 — Laws inconsistent with or in derogation of the Fundamental Rights
- Constitution of India — Art. Article 32 — Remedies for enforcement of rights conferred by this Part
- Constitution of India — Art. Article 226 — Power of High Courts to issue certain writs
Illustrations
Public Sector Undertaking as Instrumentality (Sukhdev Singh)
The Oil and Natural Gas Commission (ONGC) and Life Insurance Corporation (LIC) are statutory corporations created by Parliament. Under Sukhdev Singh and R.D. Shetty, they are instrumentalities of the State because they carry out public functions under deep governmental financial and administrative control. Their employees are entitled to invoke Articles 14 and 16 against arbitrary termination.
BCCI: Non-State Under Art 12, but Amenable to Art 226
The Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) is a private society that receives no state funding and operates without government administrative dominance. Under Zee Telefilms (2005), it is not "State" under Article 12, and an Article 32 petition will not lie against it. However, because it regulates cricket and selects the national team (a public function), a writ under Article 226 lies against it for arbitrary administrative decisions.
Problem questions
The Autonomous Research Institute and Employee Dismissal
Dr. Ananya is a senior scientist at the National Nanotechnology Institute (NNI), a society registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860. The Union Ministry of Science provides 90% of NNI's annual operating budget. The governing council consists of the Union Secretary of Science as ex-officio Chairman and four government-nominated professors. The Union Government has the power to issue binding policy directives and veto appointments. NNI summarily dismisses Dr. Ananya without a chargesheet or hearing. She files an Article 32 writ petition challenging the dismissal as violative of Article 14 and 16. NNI objects, contending it is a private registered society and not "State". Decide.
1. Piercing the Corporate Form: Under Ajay Hasia and Pradeep Kumar Biswas, the fact that NNI is a registered society and not a statutory corporation is irrelevant. 2. Applying the Biswas Cumulative Test: (a) Financial Domination: 90% funding comes from the Union Government; (b) Administrative Domination: Union Secretary chairs the governing council with government-appointed members; (c) Functional & Pervasive Control: The Union has power to issue binding directives and veto recruitments. 3. Conclusion: NNI is financially, functionally, and administratively dominated by the Union Government. It is an instrumentality of the State under Article 12. The Article 32 petition is maintainable, and the summary termination without hearing violates Articles 14 and 16.
Distinctions
- Art 12 defines State strictly for the enforcement of Part III Fundamental Rights (including Art 32 writs).
- Art 226 can issue writs against "any person or authority" discharging a public duty, even if not State under Art 12.
- A body must satisfy the deep and pervasive control test of Pradeep Kumar Biswas to be Art 12 State.
- A private body performing a public function (e.g., BCCI, private unassisted school) is amenable to Art 226 without being Art 12 State.
- Article 12 ("The State")
- Article 226 ("Any Person or Authority")
- Involves government control over internal day-to-day management, budget, appointments, and policy directives.
- Involves general statutory compliance applicable to all market players (e.g., Companies Act, RBI/SEBI regulations).
- Creates an instrumentality of State under Art 12 (Ajay Hasia; Biswas).
- Does not transform private companies or banks into Art 12 State (Federal Bank v. Sagar Thomas).
- Deep & Pervasive State Control
- General Regulatory Statutory Control
Common misconceptions
Only statutory corporations created by an Act of Parliament can be treated as "State" under Article 12.
Form is irrelevant. Under Sukhdev Singh, R.D. Shetty, and Ajay Hasia, even a company registered under the Companies Act or a society registered under the Societies Registration Act is "State" if it satisfies the instrumentality or agency test.
A citizen can file an Article 32 petition against a judicial decision of a High Court judge alleging violation of Article 14.
A judicial order passed by a court of competent jurisdiction cannot be challenged under Article 32 as violating Fundamental Rights (Naresh Mirajkar). The proper remedy is appeal, review under Article 137, or a curative petition under Article 142.
Leading cases
- Rajasthan State Electricity Board (RSEB) v. Mohan Lal (1967), AIR 1967 SC 1857 — Overruled the ejusdem generis restriction; "other authorities" in Article 12 includes all authorities created by the Constitution or statutes endowed with legal power.
- Ramana Dayaram Shetty v. International Airport Authority of India (IAAI) (1979), (1979) 3 SCC 489 — Formulated the Instrumentality or Agency Test: a corporation acting as an agency of the Government falls within Article 12 regardless of whether it is statutory or non-statutory.
- Ajay Hasia v. Khalid Mujib Sehravardi (1981), (1981) 1 SCC 722 — Laid down the definitive six-factor test to determine if a registered society or corporation is an instrumentality of the State under Article 12.
- Pradeep Kumar Biswas v. Indian Institute of Chemical Biology (2002), (2002) 5 SCC 111 — A 7-judge Bench overruled Sabhajit Tewary; held that CSIR is State because it is financially, functionally, and administratively dominated by the Government under pervasive control.
- Zee Telefilms Ltd. v. Union of India (2005), (2005) 4 SCC 649 — BCCI is not "State" under Article 12 because it is not financially or administratively dominated by the State; Article 32 petition not maintainable.
- Naresh Shridhar Mirajkar v. State of Maharashtra (1967), AIR 1967 SC 1 — A judicial order passed by a court of competent jurisdiction cannot be challenged under Article 32 as violating Fundamental Rights.
Questions & answers
Discuss the meaning of "other authorities" in Article 12 of the Constitution. Explain the six-factor test formulated in Ajay Hasia v. Khalid Mujib Sehravardi.
### 1. Synopsis / Introduction
Article 12 defines "the State" for the purpose of enforcing Part III Fundamental Rights. While the Article expressly enumerates the executive and legislative organs of the Union and States, and local authorities, the scope of **"other authorities"** has been expanded by the Supreme Court to prevent the State from evading constitutional obligations through corporate entities.
---
### 2. Meaning & Judicial Rejection of Ejusdem Generis
- Early High Court rulings (*University of Madras v. Shantha Bai*, 1954) applied *ejusdem generis*, restricting other authorities to bodies exercising governmental functions.
- In *R.S.E.B. v. Mohan Lal* (1967), the Supreme Court rejected this restrictive view, holding that "other authorities" includes all bodies created by a statute and empowered by law.
- In *R.D. Shetty v. International Airport Authority* (1979), Justice Bhagwati laid down the **instrumentality or agency test**, ruling that corporations acting as hands of the State fall within Article 12 regardless of corporate structure.
---
### 3. The 6-Factor Test in *Ajay Hasia v. Khalid Mujib Sehravardi* (1981) 1 SCC 722
In *Ajay Hasia*, a 5-judge Constitution Bench held that a registered engineering college society was "State", laying down six cumulative criteria:
1. **Share Capital:** Entire share capital held by the Government.
2. **Financial Assistance:** Financial assistance from the State meeting almost the entire expenditure of the corporation.
3. **Monopoly Status:** Corporation enjoying a State-conferred or State-protected monopoly status.
4. **Pervasive Control:** Deep and pervasive State control over governance and administration.
5. **Public Function:** Functions of the corporation being of public importance and closely related to governmental functions.
6. **Departmental Transfer:** If a government department is transferred to a corporation.
---
### 4. Conclusion
*Ajay Hasia* established that substance prevails over form: whether a body is a statutory corporation, a government company, or a registered society, it cannot escape Part III if it functions as an arm of the State.
"The concept of 'the State' under Article 12 has evolved from formal institutional identity to functional and administrative reality." Trace the jurisprudential trajectory of Article 12 from Rajasthan State Electricity Board to Pradeep Kumar Biswas. Critically examine whether private bodies discharging public functions (such as the BCCI) and the Judiciary fall within the ambit of Article 12.
### 1. Introduction: Article 12 as the Threshold of Fundamental Rights
Part III of the Constitution of India enshrines the fundamental guarantees of human liberty, equality, and dignity. However, constitutional liberties are primarily shields erected against sovereign state overreach. Consequently, Article 12 serves as the indispensable jurisdictional threshold: unless the entity infringing a right qualifies as **"the State"**, no direct writ petition under Article 32 is maintainable.
With the growth of the modern welfare state and subsequent privatization, state functions migrated from traditional ministries into statutory boards, public sector undertakings, government companies, and registered societies. The Supreme Court responded by expanding the definition of "other authorities" through purposive constitutional interpretation.
---
### 2. Historical & Jurisprudential Trajectory
#### A. The Pre-Statutory Era and Ejusdem Generis
In *University of Madras v. Shantha Bai* (AIR 1954 Mad 67), the High Court applied the rule of *ejusdem generis*, holding that "other authorities" must belong to the same genus as government and legislature, exercising sovereign functions. This excluded universities and public bodies.
#### B. The Statutory Inception: *R.S.E.B. v. Mohan Lal* (1967) 3 SCR 377
A 5-judge Constitution Bench overruled *Shantha Bai*. Justice Bhargava held that the *ejusdem generis* rule cannot apply because the bodies enumerated in Article 12 do not constitute a single genus. The Court held that "other authorities" includes **every authority created by statute or the Constitution and endowed with legal powers**.
#### C. The Instrumentality Revolution: *Sukhdev Singh* and *R.D. Shetty*
- In *Sukhdev Singh v. Bhagatram* (1975), Justice K.K. Mathew pointed out that the State conducts massive industrial, commercial, and welfare activities through statutory corporations (LIC, ONGC, IFC). To insulate them from Part III would make Fundamental Rights an illusion.
- In *Ramana Dayaram Shetty v. International Airport Authority of India (IAAI)* (1979), Justice P.N. Bhagwati formulated the **Instrumentality or Agency Test**, holding that an entity acting as an arm or agency of the State is "State", irrespective of corporate personality.
#### D. The Six-Prong Matrix: *Ajay Hasia v. Khalid Mujib Sehravardi* (1981) 1 SCC 722
The Constitution Bench crystallized six indicators of instrumentality:
1. Entire share capital owned by Government;
2. Extensive financial assistance meeting almost all operational expenditure;
3. State-conferred or protected monopoly;
4. Deep and pervasive State control;
5. Functions of public importance closely related to governmental functions;
6. Transfer of a government department to the corporation.
#### E. The Modern Benchmark: *Pradeep Kumar Biswas v. Indian Institute of Chemical Biology* (2002) 5 SCC 111
A 7-judge Constitution Bench re-evaluated the doctrine, specifically overruling *Sabhajit Tewary* (1975) which had held that the CSIR was not State.
- Justice Ruma Pal formulated the definitive modern standard:
> *"The question in each case would be whether in the light of the cumulative facts as established, the body is financially, functionally and administratively dominated by or under the pervasive control of the Government. Such control must be particular to the body in question and must be pervasive. If this is found, then the body is a State within Article 12."*
- *Biswas* established that **mere statutory regulation** (e.g., regulatory oversight by RBI, SEBI, or Companies Act) is insufficient; there must be **pervasive governmental domination**.
---
### 3. Private Bodies Performing Public Duties: The BCCI Paradigm
Can private entities performing public functions be classified as "State" under Article 12?
- In *Zee Telefilms Ltd. v. Union of India* (2005) 4 SCC 649, a 5-judge Bench examined the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI):
- BCCI was neither created by statute, nor funded by the Government, nor administratively controlled by the State.
- The Court held by 3:2 that BCCI is **not "State" under Article 12**, and an Article 32 writ petition is non-maintainable.
- **The Article 226 Dichotomy (*BCCI v. Cricket Association of Bihar*, 2015):** The Supreme Court clarified that while BCCI is not an Article 12 State, it exercises monopoly over cricket, selects national teams, and discharges public duties. Therefore, it is amenable to writ jurisdiction under Article 226. Article 226 reaches "any person or authority" performing public functions, whereas Article 12 is restricted to the "State".
---
### 4. Is the Judiciary "The State" under Article 12?
The constitutional status of the judiciary under Article 12 presents a sophisticated bifurcation:
1. **Administrative Capacity:** When higher courts perform administrative duties (e.g., appointment of staff under Art 146/229, disciplinary proceedings, or framing recruitment rules), they are unquestionably **"the State"** and must strictly observe Articles 14, 15, and 16 (*Supreme Court Employees Welfare Association v. Union of India*, 1989).
2. **Judicial Capacity:** In *Naresh Shridhar Mirajkar v. State of Maharashtra* (AIR 1967 SC 1), an 8-judge Constitution Bench held that a judicial order passed by a court of competent jurisdiction cannot be challenged under Article 32 as violative of Fundamental Rights. A judicial decision can be legally erroneous, but it cannot be an unconstitutional infringement of Part III.
3. **The Curative Remedy (*Rupa Ashok Hurra v. Ashok Hurra*, 2002):** To correct grave miscarriages of justice or violations of natural justice in final Supreme Court judgments, the Court evolved the "Curative Petition" under Article 142, reaffirming that Article 32 does not run against judicial decrees.
---
### 5. Summary Matrix: Article 12 vs Article 226 Amenability
| Category of Entity | Article 12 Status ("The State") | Article 32 Maintainability | Article 226 Maintainability |
| :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- |
| **Government Ministries & Departments** | Yes (Expressly included) | Yes | Yes |
| **Municipalities, Panchayats, Port Trusts** | Yes (Local Authority) | Yes | Yes |
| **Statutory Corporations (LIC, ONGC)** | Yes (Instrumentality - *Sukhdev*) | Yes | Yes |
| **Dominated Societies (CSIR, RECs)** | Yes (Pervasive control - *Biswas*) | Yes | Yes |
| **Private Public Bodies (BCCI, Pvt Schools)** | **No** (*Zee Telefilms*) | **No** | **Yes** (Public duty test - *Andi Mukta*) |
| **Judiciary (Judicial Orders)** | **No** (*Naresh Mirajkar*) | **No** (Remedy: Appeal/Curative) | **No** (Subject to Art 227 supervision) |
---
### 6. Conclusion
The jurisprudence of Article 12 reflects the Supreme Court's determination to maintain the relevance of Part III in a rapidly transforming socio-economic landscape. By shifting from mechanical institutional definitions in *RSEB* to substantive tests of pervasive control in *Pradeep Kumar Biswas*, while harmonizing public duty enforcement through Article 226, the Indian judiciary has prevented public power from shedding its constitutional accountability behind private veils.
Bare Act pointers
- Art 12 — Definition of State for Part III
- Art 13 — Laws inconsistent with FRs void
- Art 32 — Direct writ remedy to Supreme Court
- Art 226 — High Court writ jurisdiction over any person/authority