Freedom of Religion & Secularism (Arts 25–28)

Constitutional Law · Arts 25–28 · Conscience, ERP test, denominational autonomy & secularism (Shirur Mutt, Sabarimala)

Study notes

## 1. Constitutional Concept of Secularism & Religious Freedom

The Preamble to the Constitution declares India to be a **"SECULAR"** Republic (formalized by the 42nd Amendment, 1976). In *S.R. Bommai v. Union of India* (1994), a 9-judge Constitution Bench settled that **secularism is an inviolable basic feature** of the Constitution.

### Indian Secularism vs Western Secularism

- **Western Model (Strict Wall of Separation):** Modeled on the American First Amendment ("Establishment Clause") and French *laïcité*, mandating rigid institutional separation between the State and religious organizations.

- **Indian Model (Principled Equal Regard / *Sarva Dharma Sambhava*):** The Indian Constitution does not erect a wall of mutual exclusion. Instead, it embodies **equal tolerance and neutrality towards all religions**, coupled with an active constitutional mandate for social reform, gender justice, and the elimination of untouchability and oppressive superstitious practices (Articles 15(2), 17, 25(2)(b)).

---

## 2. Textual Anatomy: Articles 25 to 28

### Article 25: Individual Freedom of Religion

- **25(1):** All persons are equally entitled to freedom of conscience and the right freely to **profess, practice, and propagate** religion.

- *Profess:* Openly declaring one's faith.

- *Practice:* Performance of religious worship, rituals, ceremonies, and exhibitions of beliefs.

- *Propagate:* Transmitting or expounding the doctrines of one's faith for the edification of others.

- **Constitutional Restrictions:** Article 25(1) is expressly subject to: (1) **Public order**, (2) **Morality**, (3) **Health**, and (4) **Other provisions of Part III** (including Articles 14, 15, and 21).

- **25(2)(a):** State power to regulate economic, financial, political, or other secular activities associated with religious practice.

- **25(2)(b):** State power to provide for social welfare and reform, and the **throwing open of Hindu religious institutions of a public character to all classes and sections of Hindus** (Explanation II: "Hindus" includes Sikhs, Jains, and Buddhists).

- **Explanation I:** Wearing and carrying of *kirpans* is included in the profession of the Sikh religion.

### Article 26: Collective Religious Denominational Rights

Subject **only** to public order, morality, and health (notice: not explicitly subject to "other provisions of Part III"):

- (a) Establish and maintain institutions for religious and charitable purposes;

- (b) Manage its own affairs in matters of religion;

- (c) Own and acquire movable and immovable property;

- (d) Administer such property in accordance with law.

- **Denomination Defined (*Shirur Mutt*):** A collection of individuals who have a system of beliefs they regard as conducive to their spiritual well-being, a common organization, and designated by a distinctive name.

### Article 27: Prohibition of Taxes for Religious Promotion

- No person can be compelled to pay any **tax** the proceeds of which are specifically appropriated for the promotion or maintenance of any particular religion or religious denomination.

- **Tax vs Fee Distinction (*Shirur Mutt*, 1954):** The State cannot levy a tax to promote religion. However, the State may levy a **fee or regulatory contribution** upon religious trusts to meet the administrative expenses of supervising secular endowments and temple properties.

### Article 28: Religious Instruction in Educational Institutions

Four distinct categories:

1. **Wholly maintained by State funds:** Religious instruction completely **prohibited** (Art 28(1)).

2. **Administered by State but established under a Trust/Endowment:** Religious instruction **permitted** (Art 28(2)).

3. **Recognized by the State:** Voluntary; no student can be compelled without consent / parental consent (Art 28(3)).

4. **Receiving aid out of State funds:** Voluntary; no compulsory attendance (Art 28(3)).

---

## 3. The Essential Religious Practices (ERP) Doctrine

To balance religious autonomy under Article 25(1)/26(b) with the State's social reform mandate under Article 25(2), the Supreme Court evolved the **Essential Religious Practices (ERP) Test**:

- Only those practices that are **integral, foundational, and indispensable** to a religion receive constitutional immunity under Articles 25 and 26.

- Extraneous, superstitious, or accreted cultural practices do not enjoy constitutional protection and may be prohibited or regulated by the State.

### The Judicial Evolution of the ERP Test:

1. **The Origin: *Commissioner, H.R.E. v. Sri Lakshmindra Thirtha Swamiar (Shirur Mutt)* (1954):**

- Chief Justice B.K. Mukherjea ruled that what constitutes an essential part of a religion must be decided with reference to the **doctrines, texts, and tenets of that religion itself**.

2. **The Shift to Judicial Theology: *Durgah Committee, Ajmer v. Syed Hussain Ali* (1961):**

- Justice Gajendragadkar cautioned that courts must weed out secular, superstitious, or commercial accretions that masquerade as religious practices.

3. **The Tandava Dance Cases (*Acharya Jagdishwaranand*, 1983 & 2004):**

- The Supreme Court held that performing the Tandava dance with human skulls and trident in public streets is not an essential religious practice of Ananda Margis, as the faith was founded in 1955 without this practice.

4. **Triple Talaq: *Shayara Bano v. Union of India* (2017) 9 SCC 1:**

- A 5-judge Constitution Bench held that *Talaq-e-Biddat* (instant triple talaq) is not an essential religious practice in Islam, because it is recognized as sinful and un-Quranic even under Hanafi jurisprudence. It was struck down under Article 14.

5. **The Sabarimala Verdict: *Indian Young Lawyers Association v. State of Kerala* (2018) 10 SCC 1:**

- The 4:1 majority struck down the exclusionary custom barring women aged 10–50 from entering the Sabarimala temple:

- The exclusion of women is not an essential religious practice of the Hindu religion.

- Article 25(1) is expressly subject to "other provisions of Part III"—including Article 14 (gender equality), Article 15 (prohibition of sex discrimination), and Article 21 (human dignity).

- Religious customs based on biological physiological factors like menstruation violate constitutional morality.

- *Dissent of Indu Malhotra, J.:* In a pluralist democracy, constitutional morality requires the Court to respect religious faith. Essentiality should be determined by the worshippers themselves, not rationalized by judicial scrutiny.

---

## 4. Key Landmark Inquiries: Conversion and Conscience

### A. Right to Propagate vs Right to Convert: *Rev. Stainislaus v. State of M.P.* (1977)

A 5-judge Constitution Bench considered the validity of State anti-conversion laws (Freedom of Religion Acts of MP and Odisha):

- **Ratio:** Article 25(1) guarantees the right to "propagate" religion—meaning the right to transmit, expound, and disseminate the tenets of one's faith.

- **No Right to Convert:** The Court ruled that there is **no fundamental right to convert another person**. What is freedom for one person is freedom for the other: forcibly converting a person violates his freedom of conscience.

- The State is competent to enact laws prohibiting conversions procured through **force, fraud, misrepresentation, or allurement**, as such acts threaten "public order".

### B. Freedom of Conscience and National Anthem: *Bijoe Emmanuel v. State of Kerala* (1986)

Three Jehovah's Witness school children in Kerala were expelled for refusing to sing the National Anthem. They respectfully stood up during the anthem, but did not sing because their religious faith prohibited singing praise to any earthly power.

- The Supreme Court reversed the expulsion, holding that standing respectfully without singing does not cause disrespect under the Prevention of Insults to National Honour Act, 1971.

- Their expulsion violated both **freedom of speech (Art 19(1)(a))** and **freedom of conscience and religion (Art 25(1))**. Justice Chinnappa Reddy famously remarked:

> *"Our tradition teaches tolerance; our philosophy preaches tolerance; our Constitution practices tolerance; let us not dilute it."*

Articles 25–28: Textual Architecture & Constitutional Limits

Article 25 protects freedom of conscience and the profession, practice and propagation of religion, subject to public order, morality, health and the other provisions of Part III.

Article 26 protects specified denominational rights subject to public order, morality and health; Articles 27 and 28 address religious taxation and religious instruction in educational institutions.

Article 25(2) preserves State power to regulate secular activities associated with religion and to enact social-welfare and reform measures within the constitutional text.

Denominational Autonomy & Essential Religious Practices

Shirur Mutt treats religion as extending beyond abstract doctrine to protected religious practices, while the essential-practice inquiry examines the role of a practice within the faith.

The ERP doctrine must be applied with care: courts examine the religion’s doctrines, practices and constitutional context rather than treating every asserted custom as automatically immune.

Article 26(b) concerns management of affairs in matters of religion; secular administration of property remains subject to lawful regulation.

Articles 27 & 28: Taxation, Fees and Religious Instruction

Article 27 concerns compulsory payment of a tax specifically appropriated for promotion or maintenance of a particular religion or denomination; the tax/fee distinction matters.

Article 28(1) prohibits religious instruction in institutions wholly maintained out of State funds, subject to the specific constitutional exception in Article 28(2).

Article 28(3) protects individual choice in recognized institutions or institutions receiving State aid: attendance at religious instruction or worship cannot be compelled without the required consent.

Conscience, Propagation, Conversion & Constitutional Morality

The right to propagate religion does not automatically entail a fundamental right to convert another person; restrictions directed at force, fraud or coercive means engage both religious freedom and public-order concerns.

Bijoe Emmanuel illustrates the protection of conscience where conduct is respectful and does not itself constitute prohibited disrespect.

Sabarimala jurisprudence demonstrates the continuing tension between religious autonomy, equality, dignity and the scope of judicial review; disputed propositions should distinguish majority holdings from separate opinions and subsequent proceedings.

Litigation, Judicial Review & Evidentiary Roadmap

A constitutional challenge should identify the precise Article 25–28 protection, the religious body or individual affected, the State action, the applicable limitation clause, and the relief sought.

PIL and writ jurisdiction in religious-practice disputes require careful attention to maintainability, locus, factual foundation and institutional competence; the court may distinguish essential religious practice from secular regulation.

For disputed factual material, BSA ss. 104–106 provide the general burden framework and s. 109 addresses facts especially within a person’s knowledge. Electronic records relied upon in the proceeding must satisfy applicable BSA electronic-record requirements, including s. 63 where its conditions apply.

Statutory provisions

  • Constitution of India — Art. Article 25 — Freedom of conscience and free profession, practice and propagation of religion
  • Constitution of India — Art. Article 26 — Freedom to manage religious affairs
  • Constitution of India — Art. Article 27 — Freedom as to payment of taxes for promotion of any particular religion
  • Constitution of India — Art. Article 28 — Freedom as to attendance at religious instruction or worship in educational institutions

Illustrations

Tax vs Fee in Temple Administration (Shirur Mutt)

The State government levies a 5% contribution on the gross annual income of all religious mutts and temples to defray the salary and audit expenses of the Hindu Religious Endowments Department. Under Shirur Mutt (1954), this levy is a valid "fee" for supervisory services rendered to preserve trust assets, not a prohibited "tax" for the promotion of religion under Article 27.

Freedom of Conscience and National Anthem (Bijoe Emmanuel)

Jehovah's Witness children stand at respectful attention during the singing of the National Anthem in school, but do not sing the words due to conscientious religious belief. Expelling them violates Article 19(1)(a) and Article 25(1). Respectful silence is not disrespect.

Problem questions

The Temple Priesthood Hereditary Succession Dispute

State Epsilon enacts the Epsilon Temple Reform Act, abolishing the centuries-old hereditary succession of Archakas (priests) in all public Hindu temples, requiring that any qualified Hindu possessing Vedic training may be appointed as priest, regardless of caste, gotra, or lineage. An association of hereditary priests challenges the statute, claiming it violates Article 25(1) and Article 26(b) by interfering with essential religious affairs. Decide.

1. Secular Activity vs Essential Practice: In Seshammal v. State of Tamil Nadu (1972) and Adi Saiva Sivachariyargal v. State of T.N. (2016), the Supreme Court ruled that the appointment of an Archaka (priest) is a secular activity associated with religious practice, governed by Article 25(2)(a). 2. Social Reform & Article 25(2)(b): Hereditary succession based solely on birth or lineage perpetuates caste exclusions contrary to Article 14, 15, and 17. The State is fully competent under Article 25(2)(b) to open temple offices to qualified individuals. 3. Ritual Performance: While the appointment is secular, the priest once appointed must perform rituals according to the authentic Agamas of the specific temple. 4. Conclusion: Abolishing hereditary succession does not violate Article 26(b) or Article 25(1). The Act is constitutionally valid.

Distinctions

  • Guaranteed to "all persons" individually (citizens and non-citizens).
  • Guaranteed to "every religious denomination or any section thereof" collectively.
  • Expressly subject to public order, morality, health, AND "other provisions of Part III".
  • Subject textually to public order, morality, and health (omits "other provisions of Part III").
  • Protects individual freedom of conscience and worship.
  • Protects institutional autonomy to manage religious affairs and administer property.
  • Article 25 (Individual Right)
  • Article 26 (Denominational Right)
  • Fundamental right to transmit and explain the tenets of one's religion.
  • There is NO fundamental right to convert another person (Rev. Stainislaus).
  • Promotes personal expression and religious discussion.
  • Forcible, fraudulent, or lured conversions violate freedom of conscience and public order.
  • Right to Propagate (Art 25(1))
  • Right to Convert

Common misconceptions

Article 25 gives a citizen an absolute right to practice any custom or ritual that his community has followed for generations.

Customary practices do not automatically receive constitutional immunity. Under the Essential Religious Practices test, only practices indispensable and core to the religion are protected. Practices violating public order, health, morality, or gender equality under Part III can be prohibited.

Article 27 prohibits the State from spending any public revenue on repairing heritage places of worship damaged during natural disasters.

Article 27 prohibits the promotion or maintenance of any *particular* religion. In K. Raghunath v. State of Maharashtra (1971), spending secular public funds to restore all places of worship damaged in riots or earthquakes without religious bias was held not to violate Article 27.

Leading cases

  • Commissioner, H.R.E. v. Sri Lakshmindra Thirtha Swamiar (Shirur Mutt) (1954), 1954 SCR 1005 — Laid down the Essential Religious Practices test; what is essential is determined with reference to the doctrines of the religion itself; distinguished between tax and fee under Article 27.
  • S.R. Bommai v. Union of India (1994), (1994) 3 SCC 1 — 9-judge Bench declared Secularism to be an inviolable basic feature of the Constitution; politics and religion cannot be mixed by State governments.
  • Rev. Stainislaus v. State of Madhya Pradesh (1977), (1977) 1 SCC 677 — Article 25(1) right to propagate religion does not include a fundamental right to convert another person; anti-conversion statutes prohibiting force/fraud are constitutional.
  • Bijoe Emmanuel v. State of Kerala (1986), (1986) 3 SCC 615 — Expulsion of Jehovah's Witness children for not singing National Anthem violates Article 19(1)(a) and 25(1); standing respectfully is not disrespect.
  • Indian Young Lawyers Association v. State of Kerala (Sabarimala Case) (2018), (2018) 10 SCC 1 — Struck down exclusion of women aged 10–50 from Sabarimala temple; held practice was not essential to Hinduism and violated Articles 14, 15, and 21.

Questions & answers

Explain the Essential Religious Practices (ERP) Test formulated by the Supreme Court of India. Discuss its origin in the Shirur Mutt case and its application in the Sabarimala decision.

### 1. Synopsis / Introduction

The **Essential Religious Practices (ERP) Doctrine** is a judicial tool formulated by the Supreme Court of India to delineate the autonomous domain of religious freedom protected under Articles 25 and 26 from the State's regulatory and social reform powers under Article 25(2).

---

### 2. Origin: *The Shirur Mutt Case* (AIR 1954 SC 282)

In *Commissioner, H.R.E. v. Sri Lakshmindra Thirtha Swamiar (Shirur Mutt)*, Chief Justice B.K. Mukherjea laid the foundation:

- Religion encompasses not merely doctrines of belief, but acts done in pursuance of religion (rituals, ceremonies, and forms of worship).

- **The Core Rule:** What constitutes an "essential part of a religion" must be ascertained with reference to the **internal doctrines, tenets, and scriptures of the religion itself**, not by external sociological tests.

---

### 3. Judicial Evolution: Weeding Out Secular Accretions

In *Durgah Committee, Ajmer v. Syed Hussain Ali* (1961), Justice Gajendragadkar introduced a significant refinement: courts must distinguish between genuinely essential religious practices and superstitious, commercial, or secular accretions that claim religious sanctity.

---

### 4. Application in *Indian Young Lawyers Association (Sabarimala Case)* (2018)

A 5-judge Constitution Bench applied the ERP test to the custom barring women aged 10–50 from entering the Sabarimala temple:

- **Majority Ratio:** The exclusion of women is not an essential religious practice of the Hindu religion. There was no authoritative scriptural foundation establishing that the exclusion was foundational to Hinduism.

- **Subjection to Part III:** The Court emphasized that Article 25(1) is expressly subject to "other provisions of Part III". Denying entry to women based on biological physiological attributes violates Articles 14, 15, and 21.

---

### 5. Conclusion

The ERP test has transformed the judiciary into an arbiter of religious dogma. While criticized by some as judicial theology, it has acted as an essential constitutional lever to eradicate discriminatory practices and harmonize ancient faiths with constitutional morality.

"The Indian Constitution does not erect a wall of separation between Church and State, but balances religious autonomy with transformative social justice." Critically evaluate the constitutional architecture of Freedom of Religion under Articles 25 to 28. Trace the evolution of the Essential Religious Practices doctrine and analyze whether the right to propagate includes the right to convert.

### 1. Introduction: The Unique Architecture of Indian Secularism

In Western political philosophy, secularism was forged through the violent struggle between the Papacy and the Sovereign State, culminating in the American First Amendment ("Establishment Clause") and French *laïcité*—demanding a rigid, impermeable "wall of separation" between the state and religious bodies.

In sharp contrast, the Indian Constitution rejects this rigid separation. In *S.R. Bommai v. Union of India* (1994), a 9-judge Constitution Bench established that **secularism is an inviolable basic structure feature** of the Constitution. Indian secularism is grounded in the civilizational philosophy of ***Sarva Dharma Sambhava*** (equal tolerance and respect for all faiths) combined with an active constitutional mandate of social reform under Article 25(2)(b) and Article 17. The State is not anti-religious; it is non-denominational, neutral, yet committed to eradicating religious practices that violate human dignity.

---

### 2. The Textual Code: Articles 25 through 28

#### A. Article 25: Individual Freedom of Religion

Article 25(1) guarantees to *all persons* (citizens and non-citizens) freedom of conscience and the right freely to:

- **Profess:** Openly avow one's faith;

- **Practice:** Perform rites, ceremonies, and rituals;

- **Propagate:** Disseminate religious doctrines.

- **Textual Limitations:** Unlike many other fundamental rights, Article 25(1) is subject to four explicit constitutional limitations:

1. Public Order;

2. Morality;

3. Health;

4. **Other provisions of Part III** (Articles 14, 15, 17, 21).

#### B. Article 25(2): The State's Transformative Mandate

The State retains sovereign power to:

- Regulate secular, financial, or political activities linked to religious practices (Art 25(2)(a));

- Enact social welfare and reform legislation, and **throw open Hindu public temples to all sections and classes of Hindus** (Art 25(2)(b)).

#### C. Article 26: Collective Denominational Autonomy

Article 26 guarantees religious denominations (e.g., Ramakrishna Mission, Digambara Jains, Anand Margis) institutional autonomy to manage religious affairs, acquire property, and run charitable trusts.

- **The Textual Omission:** Article 26 is subject *only* to public order, morality, and health; the words "other provisions of Part III" are absent from its text. However, in *Sri Venkataramana Devaru v. State of Mysore* (1958) and *Sabarimala* (2018), the Supreme Court ruled that Article 26 cannot be read in isolation; it must be harmonized with Article 25(2)(b) and Part III.

---

### 3. The Essential Religious Practices (ERP) Test

To prevent every superstitious custom or secular activity from claiming constitutional immunity, the judiciary created the ERP test:

| Case Milestone | Doctrinal Contribution |

| :--- | :--- |

| **Shirur Mutt (1954)** | Essentiality must be determined by the **doctrines and scriptures of the religion itself** (B.K. Mukherjea, C.J.). |

| **Durgah Committee (1961)** | Courts must weed out **superstitious, commercial, and secular accretions** claiming religious status (Gajendragadkar, J.). |

| **Tandava Dance (1983 & 2004)** | Performing Tandava dance with human skulls in public streets held **not essential** to the Ananda Marga faith. |

| **Shayara Bano (2017)** | Instant Triple Talaq (*Talaq-e-Biddat*) held **not an essential practice** in Islam; struck down under Article 14. |

| **Sabarimala (2018)** | Exclusion of women held **not essential**; subordinated religious customs to constitutional morality and gender equality. |

---

### 4. Right to Propagate vs Right to Convert: *Rev. Stainislaus v. State of M.P.* (1977) 1 SCC 677

The scope of the word "propagate" under Article 25(1) was tested when Christian missionaries challenged State Freedom of Religion Acts that penalized forcible conversions:

1. **The Meaning of Propagate:** The 5-judge Constitution Bench held that to "propagate" means to transmit or spread one's religion by exposition of its tenets.

2. **No Fundamental Right to Convert:** The Court held that Article 25(1) **does not grant the right to convert another person**.

- A right to convert would impinge upon the "freedom of conscience" guaranteed to the other person.

- Freedom of conscience guarantees the right to adhere to or change one's faith voluntarily.

3. **State Competence:** The State has legislative power under "Public Order" (Entry 1, List II) to prohibit and penalize conversions procured by force, fraud, misrepresentation, or allurement.

---

### 5. Critical Reflection: Judicial Theology vs Constitutional Morality

The ERP test has generated sharp jurisprudential debate:

- **Critique (Judicial Theology):** Critics argue that judges are ill-equipped to interpret ancient Sanskrit or Arabic scriptures. By deciding what is "essential" to a religion, judges act as theological authorities rather than constitutional referees (as highlighted in Justice Indu Malhotra's dissent in *Sabarimala*).

- **Defense (Constitutional Morality):** Proponents argue that without the ERP test, the transformative vision of the Constitution would be thwarted. Entrenched practices of untouchability, Devadasi systems, female genital mutilation, and gender exclusion would claim absolute immunity under the mantle of religious freedom.

---

### 6. Conclusion

The freedom of religion under Articles 25 to 28 reflects a profound constitutional compromise. By rejecting both state theocracy and militant secularism, the Indian Constitution creates a pluralist sanctuary where diverse faiths can flourish. Through the Essential Religious Practices doctrine, the Supreme Court has ensured that religious autonomy bows before human dignity, equality, and the paramount ideals of constitutional morality.

Bare Act pointers

  • Art 25(1) — Freedom of conscience and profession, practice, propagation
  • Art 25(2)(b) — Throwing open public Hindu temples to all classes
  • Art 26 — Denominational rights to manage religious affairs & property
  • Art 27 — Prohibition of taxes for promoting specific religion
  • Art 28 — Regulation of religious instruction in educational institutions
  • BSA ss. 104–106 — General burden framework for disputed facts
  • BSA s. 109 — Facts especially within knowledge
  • BSA s. 63 — Electronic records where its statutory conditions apply

Judgments on this provision