Jurisdiction

Code of Civil Procedure (CPC)

s. 9 cognisance of civil suits. ss. 15–20 which court. s. 21 objection to place of suing.

Study notes

Introduction

Jurisdiction in CPC is three questions. One: can a civil court hear this at all (s. 9). Two: which court, by subject, territory and pecuniary limits (ss. 6, 15–20). Three: what happens if the wrong court is chosen (s. 21, s. 21A).

Essentials

1. Subject-matter — civil nature, not barred.

2. Territorial — property (ss. 16–17), person or residual cause (ss. 19–20).

3. Pecuniary — s. 6 and s. 15 (lowest grade competent court).

4. Objection to place of suing must be taken at the earliest opportunity and only if there was a consequent failure of justice (s. 21).

Illustration

Contract made in Pune, broken in Nashik, defendant lives in Nagpur. Residual suit — s. 20 lets the plaintiff choose any of those courts.

Fail-illustration

Title to land in Nashik filed in Nagpur only because the defendant lives there. s. 16 governs. s. 20 does not.

Authority

Dhulabhai AIR 1969 SC 78 — exclusion of jurisdiction is strict.

ABC Laminart AIR 1989 SC 1239 — part of cause of action.

Pathumma AIR 1981 SC 1683 — s. 21 timing.

Close with ss. 9, 15–21 CPC, 1908.

Illustrations

s. 20 venue works

Contract, breach and residence in three cities — any of the three.

s. 20 fails

Land-title suit cannot follow the defendant under s. 20.

Leading cases

  • Dhulabhai v. State of M.P. (1968), AIR 1969 SC 78 — Civil-court exclusion is read strictly.
  • ABC Laminart Pvt. Ltd. v. A.P. Agencies (1989), AIR 1989 SC 1239 — Cause of action may arise in part.

Questions & answers

Explain jurisdiction under the CPC.

Introduction. Jurisdiction is competence.

Heads. Subject-matter (s. 9), territorial (ss. 16–20), pecuniary (ss. 6, 15).

s. 21. Place-of-suing objection is timely and needs failure of justice.

Illustration and ABC Laminart.

Conclusion. Cite ss. 9 and 15–21 CPC, 1908.

A title suit is filed in the defendant’s city. Advise.

Issue. Is the court competent?

Rule. Land → s. 16. Residual → s. 20. Objection → s. 21.

Application. Title is not a s. 20 suit. Return the plaint under Order VII r. 10 or reject if hopeless.

Conclusion. File in the court where the land lies.

Exam tips

  • Draw the three heads before you write the facts.

Judgments on this provision