FL-II Unit III — Testamentary Succession

Family Law

FL-II Unit III — Wills: Hindu testamentary power (HSA s. 6 interest); Indian Succession Act formalities; Muslim one-third rule.

Study notes

Topic at a glance

Family Law – II, Unit III: Testamentary succession — disposition by will. For Hindus, HSA recognises testamentary power (subject to the Act). Formalities are largely under the Indian Succession Act, 1925. Always separate intestate from testamentary succession.

Introduction

Intestate succession applies when there is no valid will (or as to property not covered). Testamentary succession applies when a valid will operates.

Hindus and testamentary power

A Hindu may dispose by will of property capable of being disposed of by him. Mitakshara coparcenary interest is subject to s. 6 HSA. Self-acquired property is ordinarily freely disposable subject to general law.

Indian Succession Act, 1925 (essentials)

Sound disposing mind; execution and attestation (generally two witnesses for unprivileged wills); revocation by later will, destruction with intent, etc. Probate establishes the will.

Muslim law (brief)

Generally only up to one-third of the net estate to a non-heir without heirs’ consent; bequests to heirs or excess need consent as classical rules provide.

Current-law close

State whether the problem is intestate or testamentary. Cite HSA s. 6 and ISA formalities for Hindus; one-third rule for Muslims.

Illustrations

Example — self-acquired property

Hindu male executes a valid attested will of his self-acquired house. On death the will governs that house.

Problem questions

Classroom problem — no will

Hindu male dies leaving ancestral Mitakshara property and no will. Heirs: widow, son, daughter.

Which regime applies?

Hindu Succession Act, 1956 — ss. 6 and 8 (intestate).

No will → intestate. Ascertain interest under s. 6; devolve under s. 8 on Class I heirs.

Apply intestate HSA rules, not testamentary law.

Distinctions

Intestate vs Testamentary

  • Trigger: No valid will / Valid will covers the property
  • Hindu statute: HSA ss. 8, 15 etc. / Will + HSA s. 6 limits + ISA formalities
  • Intestate
  • Testamentary

Common misconceptions

A will automatically overrides all coparcenary rights without s. 6 HSA.

Testamentary power over Mitakshara coparcenary interest is controlled by s. 6 HSA.

Questions & answers

Explain testamentary succession under Hindu law.

Introduction. Meaning of will. Power over disposable property. s. 6 HSA and coparcenary interest. ISA formalities essentials. Conclusion.

Separate self-acquired from coparcenary interest.

Distinguish intestate and testamentary succession. Discuss limits on willing Mitakshara interest and the Muslim one-third rule.

Introduction. Intestate vs testamentary. Hindu: HSA intestate vs will; s. 6 on coparcenary interest. Muslim: one-third rule. Illustration. Conclusion.

Both Hindu s. 6 and Muslim one-third needed.

Bare Act pointers

  • Hindu Succession Act, 1956 — s. 6
  • Indian Succession Act, 1925 — wills

Exam tips

  • First ask: is there a valid will?
  • Muslim wills: one-third rule.

Revision points

  • Intestate = no will; testamentary = will.
  • HSA s. 6 limits on coparcenary interest.
  • Muslim — generally 1/3 to non-heir without consent.