Format 4: Written Statement under Order VIII CPC

Petition Formats & Drafting · Order VIII CPC; denial, set-off, counter-claim

Study notes

Core Drafting Skeleton & Rules for Written Statement (Order VIII CPC)

1. Cause Title & Heading

• In the Court of the Civil Judge / District Judge at [Station]

• Original Suit No. … of 20…

• [Plaintiff Name] … Plaintiff vs. [Defendant Name] … Defendant

• "WRITTEN STATEMENT ON BEHALF OF DEFENDANT NO. 1 UNDER ORDER VIII RULE 1 CPC"

2. Mandatory Timelines for Filing

• General Civil Suits (CPC Order VIII Rule 1): 30 days from service of summons; extendable up to 90 days for reasons recorded in writing (held directory in exceptional cases: Salem Bar / Kailash v. Nanhku).

• Commercial Suits (Commercial Courts Act, 2015): 30 days extendable up to 120 days with costs. Failure to file within 120 days leads to forfeiture of the right to file WS; court cannot condone delay beyond 120 days (SCG Contracts).

3. Preliminary Objections (Pleading Threshold Bars)

• Lack of jurisdiction: Territorial, pecuniary, or subject-matter bar.

• Bar of limitation: Suit barred under the Limitation Act, 1963.

• Non-compliance with statutory notice: E.g., lack of mandatory 2-month notice under Section 80 CPC against Government authorities.

• Non-joinder or misjoinder of necessary parties (Order I Rule 9).

• Bar of Res Judicata (Section 11) or Order II Rule 2.

4. Para-wise Reply & The Doctrine of Non-Traverse

• Specific Denial (Order VIII Rules 3 & 4): The defendant must deal specifically with each allegation of fact. General or evasive denial is impermissible.

• Deemed Admission (Order VIII Rule 5): Any allegation of fact not denied specifically or by necessary implication is taken to be admitted by the defendant, except against persons under disability.

5. New Facts & Affirmative Defences (Order VIII Rule 2)

• Payment, release, accord and satisfaction, fraud, illegality, or limitation must be raised expressly.

6. Set-Off (Rule 6) & Counter-Claim (Rule 6A to 6G)

• Legal Set-Off (Rule 6): Ascertained sum of money legally recoverable, where both parties fill the same character.

• Counter-Claim (Rule 6A): Cause of action accruing before or after filing the suit, but before defendant delivers defense or time has expired. Treated as a cross-suit; subject to separate court-fee.

7. Relief / Prayer

• Dismissal of the plaintiff's suit with costs and exemplary costs under Section 35A CPC.

• Decree on counter-claim / set-off if claimed.

8. Verification Clause & Supporting Affidavit (Order VI Rule 15 CPC)

Leading cases

  • Salem Advocate Bar Association v. Union of India (2005), (2005) 6 SCC 344 — The 90-day outer limit for filing a written statement in ordinary civil suits under Order VIII Rule 1 is directory, not mandatory, but extension must be for recorded exceptional circumstances.
  • SCG Contracts India Pvt. Ltd. v. K.S. Chamankar Infrastructure (2019), (2019) 12 SCC 210 — The 120-day outer limit for filing a WS in Commercial Suits under the Commercial Courts Act proviso to Order VIII Rule 1 is strictly mandatory and non-extendable by inherent powers.
  • Badat & Co. v. East India Trading Co. (1964), AIR 1964 SC 538 — Under Order VIII Rules 3, 4, and 5 CPC, vague or evasive denials constitute constructive admissions; denial must be specific and direct.

Bare Act pointers

  • Order VIII Rules 1–10 CPC
  • Order VIII Rule 6 (Set-off)
  • Order VIII Rule 6A–6G (Counter-claim)
  • Order VI Rule 15 & 15A CPC (Verification)
  • Section 35A CPC (Compensatory costs)

Exam tips

  • AIBE frequently tests the 30-day and 90-day time limits under Order VIII Rule 1.
  • Remember the difference between Legal Set-Off (ascertained sum) and Counter-Claim (can be unliquidated damages or independent cause of action).
  • Doctrine of Non-Traverse (Order VIII Rule 5) means silence equals admission in civil pleadings.
  • Commercial suits forfeit WS rights strictly on Day 121 with zero inherent power relaxation.