Asian Resurfacing of Road Agency Pvt. Ltd. v. Central Bureau of Investigation (2018)

Supreme Court of India · (2018) 16 SCC 299 · 3-Judge Bench

Summary

Influential 3-judge bench decision directing that in all pending civil and criminal matters where a stay of trial had been granted by a High Court or subordinate court, the stay would automatically lapse upon the expiration of six months unless extended by a reasoned speaking order. (This 6-month automatic vacation rule was subsequently overruled by a 5-judge Constitution Bench in High Court Bar Association, Allahabad v. State of U.P. in 2024).

Facts

  • In a CBI corruption prosecution under the Prevention of Corruption Act against Asian Resurfacing of Road Agency Pvt. Ltd., the trial court framed charges against the accused.
  • The accused challenged the order framing charges by filing a petition under Section 482 CrPC before the Delhi High Court, and obtained an interim stay of the trial.
  • The stay continued for years without final disposal, completely stalling the criminal trial.
  • The matter came before a 3-judge bench of the Supreme Court to address the widespread crisis of trials stalled indefinitely by interim stay orders.

Issues

  • Whether orders framing charges under the Prevention of Corruption Act can be challenged under Section 482 CrPC.
  • Whether the Supreme Court can direct that interim stay orders granted by High Courts in civil and criminal trials shall automatically expire after six months.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

The six-month automatic vacation directive

Goel, J. held that remedies against framing of charges must be exercised with extreme caution. To eliminate the menace of indefinite stays, the Court directed that in all pending cases, civil or criminal, where stay of proceedings in a trial is granted, the stay shall automatically lapse after six months unless extended by a speaking order showing exceptional circumstances.

Duty of trial courts after six months

Trial courts were directed to automatically resume trials upon expiry of six months from the date of the stay order without waiting for formal communication from the High Court.

Decision

Appeals disposed of. The Supreme Court laid down the 6-month automatic expiration rule for interim stay orders. (Overruled by 5-judge bench in High Court Bar Association, Allahabad in 2024).

Ratio decidendi

In all cases where a stay of proceedings in a civil or criminal trial has been granted, the stay order shall automatically lapse after six months unless extended by a reasoned speaking order. (Note: Overruled by Constitution Bench in 2024).

Exam points

  • Origin of the controversial "6-month automatic vacation of stay" rule in Indian procedural law.
  • Explicitly overruled by the 5-judge Constitution Bench in High Court Bar Association, Allahabad (2024).
  • Important milestone in the procedural debate between speedy trials and judicial discretion.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, BNSS, CrPC, CPC, Stay of Proceedings, 6-Month Rule, Asian Resurfacing

All judgments