Appeals & Revision

Criminal Procedure (BNSS / CrPC)

Appeals are BNSS Chapter XXXI, ss. 413–435 (old CrPC 372–394). Revision is Chapter XXXII, ss. 438–445 (old 397–405). There is no appeal except as provided. The victim’s appeal against acquittal / lesser offence / inadequate compensation is the proviso to s. 413.

Study notes

Topic at a glance

Appeal is a statutory right where granted. Revision is discretionary supervision. Do not write “I will revise because I lost the appeal”.

s. 413

No appeal lies except as provided by the BNSS or any other law.

Proviso: the victim may appeal against acquittal, conviction for a lesser offence, or inadequate compensation, to the Court to which an appeal against conviction by that Court would lie.

s. 415 — appeals from convictions

High Court extraordinary original criminal jurisdiction → Supreme Court.

Sessions Judge / Additional Sessions Judge, or any Court passing more than seven years → High Court.

Otherwise, Magistrate first/second class → Court of Session.

Specified sexual-offence conviction appeals are to be disposed of within six months of filing (s. 415(4) teaching).

No appeal on a guilty plea except as to the extent or legality of sentence (s. 416 teaching).

State appeal against inadequate sentence is s. 418 (old 377). State/complainant appeal against acquittal is the old 378 family — confirm the current BNSS number before filing or drafting submissions (often taught near s. 419).

Revision — ss. 438–445

High Court or Sessions Judge may call for the record to satisfy itself as to correctness, legality or propriety of any finding, sentence or order, and as to regularity of proceedings. No revision against an interlocutory order (the old 397(2) bar continues — confirm). Concurrent revision is not to be entertained. Revision cannot convert a finding of acquittal into conviction (the old 401(3) idea — confirm).

Reference

A subordinate Court may refer a question (ss. 436–437 teaching).

Inherent power

s. 528 (old 482) is the High Court’s inherent power to give effect to the Sanhita, prevent abuse, or secure the ends of justice. It is not an extra appeal. Bhajan Lal categories still teach quashing.

Current-law position

Cite 413 / 415 / 438 / 528. Do not write 372 / 374 / 397 / 482 as current except as concordance.

Educational note

needs-review of the exact BNSS section for State appeal against acquittal if you have not opened the Bare Act in the hall.

Statutory provisions

  • Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 — s. s. 413 — No appeal to lie unless otherwise provided
  • Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 — s. s. 415 — Appeals from convictions
  • Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 — s. s. 438 — Calling for records to exercise powers of revision
  • Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 — s. s. 528 — Saving of inherent powers of High Court

Illustrations

Example 1 — simple

A Magistrate convicts and sentences A to two years. A’s appeal is to the Court of Session (s. 415(3)), not straight to the High Court.

Example 2 — legal

The accused is acquitted. The victim may appeal under the s. 413 proviso. That is not the same thing as a revision, and it is not the State’s appeal against acquittal.

Problem questions

Examination hypothetical

A Sessions Judge acquits. The victim files a revision. The State does nothing. The victim’s lawyer says revision is “safer”.

What is the correct remedy?

s. 413 proviso — victim’s appeal against acquittal; revision is discretionary and generally not a substitute when an appeal lies.

An acquittal by a Sessions Court is appealable. The victim has a statutory appeal under the s. 413 proviso to the High Court (the Court to which a conviction-appeal would lie). Revision in the teeth of an appeal is the wrong tool. The High Court may still, in a rare case, treat one as the other, but the student should file the appeal.

Appeal under s. 413 proviso, not revision. Educational hypothetical.

Distinctions

Appeal and revision

  • Nature: Statutory right where granted; facts and law / Discretionary; legality, propriety, regularity
  • Acquittal → conviction: Appellate Court may reverse / Cannot convert acquittal into conviction
  • Interlocutory order: Only if a statute gives an appeal / Generally barred
  • Appeal (ss. 413–435)
  • Revision (ss. 438–445)

Common misconceptions

Every order of a criminal court is appealable.

s. 413: no appeal unless the Sanhita or another law gives one.

Revision can be used to convict after an acquittal.

The old 401(3) discipline continues: revision is not a back-door conviction.

Leading cases

  • Akalu Ahir v. Ramdeo Ram (1973), (1973) 2 SCC 583 — Revision is not an appeal in disguise. Interference with acquittal in revision is tightly limited.
  • Madhu Limaye v. State of Maharashtra (1977), (1977) 4 SCC 551 — What is an interlocutory order for the revision bar. Intermediate orders that affect rights may still be revisable.

Questions & answers

Who may appeal against an acquittal besides the State?

The victim, under the proviso to s. 413, against acquittal, lesser offence, or inadequate compensation.

What is the BNSS home of CrPC 482 inherent power?

s. 528.

Bare Act pointers

  • BNSS ss. 413–435
  • s. 415
  • ss. 438–445
  • s. 528
  • CrPC 372–397 / 482 (historical)

Exam tips

  • If the question is “interlocutory order”, Madhu Limaye plus the revision bar is the answer, not the appeal chapter.

Answer skeleton

  • Introduction — no appeal except as provided.
  • s. 415 forums.
  • Victim proviso.
  • Revision limits.
  • s. 528.
  • Conclusion.

Revision points

  • 413 no appeal unless provided; victim proviso.
  • 415: Magistrate → Sessions; Sessions / >7 years → HC.
  • Revision ≠ appeal. Cannot convict in revision.
  • 482 CrPC → 528 BNSS.

Judgments on this provision

Related topics