Union Carbide Corporation v. Union of India (1991)
Supreme Court of India · (1991) 4 SCC 584 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench
Summary
The 5-Judge Constitution Bench reviewed the historic court-assisted settlement of $470 million (Rs. 750 crores) between the Union of India and Union Carbide Corporation (UCC) for the catastrophic 1984 Bhopal Gas Leak disaster. The Court upheld the overall civil compensation settlement under Article 142 plenary powers, holding that the State had a duty to make good any shortfall, but struck down the withdrawal and quashing of criminal prosecutions against UCC and its officials as impermissible in law.
Facts
- On the night of 2-3 December 1984, lethal Methyl Isocyanate (MIC) gas leaked from the pesticide plant of Union Carbide India Limited (UCIL) in Bhopal, killing over 3,000 citizens immediately, injuring over 500,000 people, and permanently disabling thousands.
- Parliament enacted the Bhopal Gas Leak Disaster (Processing of Claims) Act, 1985, giving the Central Government exclusive power to represent all victims.
- On 14-15 February 1989, the Supreme Court recorded a full and final settlement of all civil claims and criminal liabilities for $470 million.
- Victims' organizations and activists challenged the settlement under review petitions, contending that the compensation was grossly inadequate, victims were not heard, and criminal prosecutions could not be quashed for money.
Issues
- Whether the court-assisted settlement of $470 million was just, fair, and equitable under Article 142.
- Whether the Supreme Court had the power under Article 142 to quash and drop criminal prosecutions against Union Carbide executives as part of a civil settlement.
- What liability falls upon the Union Government if the settlement fund proves insufficient to satisfy all victim claims.
Provisions involved
- Constitution of India — Art. Article 142 — Enforcement of decrees and orders of Supreme Court and orders as to doing complete justice
- Bhopal Gas Leak Disaster (Processing of Claims) Act, 1985 — s. Section 3 & 4 — Power of Central Government to represent claimants
Reasoning
Validity of civil compensation and State responsibility for shortfall
Venkatachaliah, J. held that the settlement figure of $470 million was reasonable and justified on the basis of medical categories and actuarial estimates. However, the Court ruled that if the settlement fund proved insufficient to satisfy all legitimate claims, the Union of India, having assumed parens patriae responsibility under the Act, is bound to make good any deficiency.
Re-opening of criminal prosecutions
The Court held that the drop of criminal proceedings was unlawful. Criminal liability cannot be compounded or quashed as part of a civil financial compromise. Article 142 powers cannot be used to subvert fundamental principles of criminal justice. The Court directed the revival of criminal cases against UCC and its officials.
Decision
Civil settlement of $470 million upheld; criminal proceedings against UCC and officials ordered revived; Union Government held liable for any shortfall.
Ratio decidendi
The plenary power of the Supreme Court under Article 142 cannot be used to extinguish criminal liability in consideration of a financial compromise in tort; the State as parens patriae must bridge any shortfall in victim compensation.
Exam points
- Upheld $470 million settlement under Article 142.
- Quashed the drop of criminal proceedings and ordered criminal trial revived.
- Held the Union of India liable to make good any shortfall in compensation.
- Benchmark on the scope and limitations of Article 142 plenary powers.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Tort, Article 142, Bhopal Gas, Absolute Liability, Settlement