B.P. Singhal v. Union of India (2010)

Supreme Court of India · (2010) 6 SCC 331 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench

Summary

Historic 5-judge Constitution Bench judgment expounding the doctrine of pleasure under Article 156(1) of the Constitution regarding the removal of State Governors. Held that while the President can remove a Governor without showing cause or prior hearing, the power cannot be exercised arbitrarily, capriciously, or merely due to a change of Government at the Centre.

Facts

  • Following the change of central government in 2004, the newly elected UPA Government advised the President to remove the Governors of Uttar Pradesh, Gujarat, Haryana, and Goa.
  • B.P. Singhal, a former Member of Parliament, filed a PIL under Article 32 challenging the wholesale removal of Governors based solely on their political ideologies.
  • The Union of India contended that Article 156(1) embodies an unfettered and absolute "doctrine of pleasure" not subject to judicial review.

Issues

  • What is the scope and limitation of the doctrine of pleasure under Article 156(1) of the Constitution.
  • Can the President remove a Governor merely because the political party in power at the Centre has changed.
  • Is the Presidential decision to remove a Governor subject to judicial review under Article 32 or 226.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Doctrine of pleasure is not a license for arbitrariness

Raveendran, J. held that in a constitutional republic governed by the rule of law, there is no place for absolute, arbitrary, or uncanalized power. The doctrine of pleasure under Article 156(1) does not mean the President can act at will, whim, or fancy.

Grounds of removal and judicial review

A Governor cannot be removed merely because he is not acceptable to the new ruling party at the Centre or holds a different political ideology. However, the President need not issue a show-cause notice or record reasons in the order. If an aggrieved Governor establishes prima facie that the removal was arbitrary, mala fide, or based on extraneous grounds, the court can grant judicial review.

Decision

Writ petition disposed of. The constitutional principles governing Article 156(1) settled: pleasure is not absolute; removal for political ideology alone is unconstitutional.

Ratio decidendi

Under Article 156(1) of the Constitution, the doctrine of pleasure is subject to constitutional limitations. Although the President need not give reasons or hold an enquiry before removing a Governor, the power cannot be exercised arbitrarily, mala fide, or on extraneous grounds such as a change of regime at the Centre. Such removal is subject to limited judicial review.

Exam points

  • Leading Constitution Bench decision on Article 156(1) doctrine of pleasure.
  • Dismissal of Governors cannot be based on mere change of ruling party at Centre.
  • Limited judicial review available against arbitrary or mala fide removal.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Article 156, Doctrine of Pleasure, Federalism, Governor

All judgments