Executive Powers: Ordinances & Pardoning (Arts 72, 123, 161, 213)

Constitutional Law · Arts 72, 123, 161, 213 · Anti-ordinance raj (D.C. Wadhwa, Krishna Kumar Singh) & clemency review (Maru Ram, Epuru Sudhakar)

Study notes

## 1. Constitutional Design of Executive Discretion

In the parliamentary system of governance established by the Indian Constitution, the President (Article 53) and the Governors (Article 154) are constitutional heads of the Union and the States. They exercise sovereign executive powers strictly on the **aid and advice of the Council of Ministers** headed by the Prime Minister or Chief Minister (Articles 74 and 163; *Shamsher Singh v. State of Punjab*, 1974).

Among these sovereign prerogatives, two powers have witnessed critical constitutional litigation:

1. **Ordinance-Making Power:** Legislative power vested in the Executive (Article 123 for the President, Article 213 for Governors);

2. **Pardoning Power:** Sovereign mercy to commute, remit, or pardon criminal convictions (Article 72 for the President, Article 161 for Governors).

---

## 2. The Ordinance-Making Power: Articles 123 and 213

### A. Textual Conditions Precedent:

An Ordinance is an exceptional legislative power enabling the Executive to respond to urgent crises when Parliament or the State Legislature is not in session:

1. **Recess of the Legislature:** Both Houses of Parliament (or the State Legislature), or at least one House, must not be in session. An Ordinance cannot be promulgated when both Houses are sitting.

2. **Subjective Satisfaction of Immediate Action:** The President or Governor must be satisfied that *"circumstances exist which render it necessary for him to take immediate action"*.

3. **Co-Extensive with Legislative Competence:** An Ordinance has the same force and effect as an Act of the Legislature, but is subject to the identical constitutional limitations (it cannot violate Part III or exceed Seventh Schedule entries; Article 123(3) & 213(3)).

4. **Parliamentary Scrutiny:** Every Ordinance must be laid before both Houses upon reassembly. It **ceases to operate at the expiration of six weeks** from the date of reassembly, or earlier if disapproved by resolutions of both Houses.

---

## 3. The Judicial War on "Ordinance Raj": *D.C. Wadhwa* to *Krishna Kumar Singh*

### A. Re-Promulgation as a Fraud on the Constitution: *D.C. Wadhwa v. State of Bihar* (1987) 1 SCC 378

Dr. D.C. Wadhwa, an economics professor, filed a writ petition exposing that between 1967 and 1981, the Governor of Bihar promulgated **256 Ordinances**, keeping them alive for up to 14 years by mechanically re-promulgating them immediately upon the prorogation of each legislative session, without ever tabling them before the Assembly!

- Chief Justice P.N. Bhagwati delivered a historic condemnation:

> *"The executive cannot by-pass the legislature and arrogate to itself the power of law-making. The re-promulgation of ordinances without submitting them to the legislature is a subversive use of constitutional power and a brazen fraud on the Constitution."*

- The Court ruled that mechanical re-promulgation of ordinances without legislative consideration is unconstitutional and void.

### B. The 7-Judge Benchmark: *Krishna Kumar Singh v. State of Bihar* (2017) 3 SCC 1

A 7-judge Constitution Bench settled the modern law on ordinances by a 5:2 majority:

1. **Mandatory Duty to Lay Before Legislature:** The requirement to lay an ordinance before the legislature under Article 123(2) and Article 213(2) is a **mandatory constitutional command**, not directory. Failure to lay an ordinance is an abuse of constitutional power.

2. **Re-promulgation is Unconstitutional:** Repeated re-promulgation without placing the ordinance before the legislature is a fraud on the constitutional scheme and subverts parliamentary democracy.

3. **Executive Satisfaction is Subject to Judicial Review:** The Court held that the President's or Governor's satisfaction under Articles 123 and 213 is **not immune from judicial review**. The Court can examine whether:

- There was any objective material before the executive;

- The satisfaction was based on extraneous grounds;

- The exercise was a colourable attempt to bypass legislative debate.

4. **Survival of Rights:** Rights created under an expired or disapproved ordinance do not automatically survive permanently. Survival depends on whether the rights are of an enduring character and whether retrospective undoing would prejudice public interest.

---

## 4. The Sovereign Mercy: Pardoning Power (Articles 72 and 161)

The power of pardon is an ancient sovereign prerogative designed to temper the rigour of strict law with human compassion, correct judicial errors, or serve state policy.

### The Five Forms of Clemency:

1. **Pardon:** Completely absolves the offender from guilt and punishment, wiping out the conviction and restoring civil status as if the offence had never been committed.

2. **Commutation:** Substitution of a heavier form of punishment with a lighter form (e.g., death sentence commuted to life imprisonment).

3. **Remission:** Reduction of the quantum or duration of the sentence without changing its legal character (e.g., 10 years rigorous imprisonment reduced to 7 years).

4. **Respite:** Postponement or awarding of a lesser sentence on special grounds (e.g., pregnancy of a female prisoner or mental illness).

5. **Reprieve:** Temporary stay of the execution of a sentence (especially death penalty) to enable the convict to seek presidential mercy.

---

## 5. Comparative Scope: President (Art 72) vs Governor (Art 161)

| Parameter | President (Article 72) | Governor (Article 161) |

| :--- | :--- | :--- |

| **Jurisdictional Extent** | Offences against Union Laws (List I & III). | Offences against State Laws (List II & III). |

| **Court-Martial Sentences** | Power extends to sentences by military courts-martial (Art 72(1)(a)). | **No power** over courts-martial sentences. |

| **Death Sentences** | Power extends to all cases of death sentence (Art 72(1)(c)). | Power extends to remit or commute death sentences (*Raj Kumar @ Titto*, 2021). |

*(Note on Death Penalty: In State of Haryana v. Raj Kumar @ Titto (2021) 9 SCC 292, the Supreme Court clarified that the Governor under Article 161 can pardon or remit life convicts who were sentenced to death, overriding Section 433A of the CrPC).*

---

## 6. Judicial Review of Pardoning Power: *Maru Ram*, *Kehar Singh*, and *Epuru Sudhakar*

### A. Aid and Advice of Council of Ministers: *Maru Ram v. Union of India* (1980) 2 SCC 107

A 5-judge Constitution Bench held that the President or Governor does not exercise the pardoning power in their personal discretion. They are **bound to act strictly on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers** under Articles 74 and 163. A rejection or acceptance of mercy by the Ministry is legally the act of the President/Governor.

### B. Constitutional Character of Mercy: *Kehar Singh v. Union of India* (1989) 1 SCC 204

In the Indira Gandhi assassination case, the Supreme Court held:

- The pardoning power is an act of sovereign grace. The President does not sit as a fourth court of appeal; he can re-examine the evidence on merits to determine whether mercy is warranted.

- The convict has **no right to an oral hearing** before the President.

- The order of the President is subject to limited judicial review only to ensure that the constitutional power was not exercised arbitrarily.

### C. Grounds of Judicial Review: *Epuru Sudhakar v. Govt. of A.P.* (2006) 8 SCC 161

A Congress party worker convicted of murder had his 10-year sentence remitted by the Governor on political grounds. The Supreme Court struck down the remission, laying down the **four grounds of judicial review** of mercy orders:

1. **Non-application of mind;**

2. **Mala fides / Malice in law;**

3. **Reliance on extraneous or wholly irrelevant considerations;**

4. **Arbitrariness, political favoritism, caste, or religious bias.**

### D. Inordinate Delay and Article 21: *Shatrughan Chauhan v. Union of India* (2014) 3 SCC 1

A 3-judge Bench held that **unexplained, inordinate, and unreasonable delay** by the Executive in deciding a mercy petition of a death row convict constitutes cruel and inhuman treatment violating **Article 21**. Such prolonged delay is a supervening circumstance justifying the **automatic commutation of the death sentence to life imprisonment**.

Evidence and litigation anchor

For constitutional challenges involving disputed factual predicates, counsel should identify the burden of proof under Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 sections 104–106, apply section 109 only where the relevant fact is especially within a person's knowledge, and address electronic records under section 63 where applicable. These provisions support proof of facts; they do not alter the constitutional standard of review.

Ordinance-Making Power: Articles 123 & 213 Architecture

Exceptional legislative power when legislature is prorogued; co-extensive with legislative lists and Part III.

Must be laid before legislature; expires after 6 weeks from reassembly.

Anti-Ordinance Raj: D.C. Wadhwa & Krishna Kumar Singh

D.C. Wadhwa (1987): Re-promulgating ordinances without submitting them to the legislature is a fraud on the Constitution.

Krishna Kumar Singh (2017 - 7 judges): Laying ordinances is a mandatory constitutional duty; executive satisfaction is subject to judicial review.

Pardoning Power: Five Forms & President vs Governor (Arts 72 & 161)

Five forms: Pardon (total extinction of guilt), Commutation, Remission, Respite, and Reprieve.

President has exclusive jurisdiction over military courts-martial; Governor can remit death sentences under Art 161 (Raj Kumar).

Aid & Advice, Judicial Review & Delay (Maru Ram, Epuru Sudhakar & Shatrughan)

Maru Ram: Exercised strictly on aid and advice of the Council of Ministers, not personal whim.

Epuru Sudhakar: Reviewable for mala fides, extraneous considerations, or political/caste bias.

Shatrughan Chauhan: Inordinate executive delay in mercy petitions violates Article 21 and commutes death penalty to life.

Statutory provisions

  • Constitution of India — Art. Article 72 — Power of President to grant pardons, etc., and to suspend, remit or commute sentences in certain cases
  • Constitution of India — Art. Article 123 — Power of President to promulgate Ordinances during recess of Parliament
  • Constitution of India — Art. Article 161 — Power of Governor to grant pardons, etc., and to suspend, remit or commute sentences in certain cases
  • Constitution of India — Art. Article 213 — Power of Governor to promulgate Ordinances during recess of Legislature

Illustrations

Mechanical Re-Promulgation of Ordinances (D.C. Wadhwa)

The State government promulgates the Land Revenue Ordinance during assembly recess. When the assembly meets for a 4-week session, the government does not introduce a Bill. On the day the assembly is prorogued, the Governor immediately promulgates an identical Ordinance. This process is repeated 10 times over 6 years. Under D.C. Wadhwa and Krishna Kumar Singh, this is an unconstitutional subversion of legislative democracy and a fraud on the Constitution. The Ordinance is void ab initio.

Political Remission of Sentence Invalidated (Epuru Sudhakar)

A politically influential convict sentenced to 10 years imprisonment for the murder of an opposition leader receives a wholesale remission from the Governor within six months, citing "good conduct" despite zero reports from prison authorities. The opposition challenges the remission. Under Epuru Sudhakar (2006), the order was passed on extraneous political considerations and without application of mind. The High Court will quash the remission and send the convict back to jail.

Problem questions

The Death Row Mercy Delay and Commutation Petition

Kartik was sentenced to death in 2012 for a heinous terrorist bombing, confirmed by the Supreme Court in 2014. Kartik submitted a mercy petition to the President under Article 72 in February 2014. The Ministry of Home Affairs kept the mercy file pending without taking any decision or seeking any clarification for nine full years. In May 2023, the President rejected the mercy petition, and a black warrant for execution was issued. Kartik's counsel files an Article 32 writ petition seeking commutation of the death sentence to life imprisonment. The Union argues that terrorism cases are exempt from judicial review of mercy delays. Decide.

1. Constitutional Right under Article 21: In Shatrughan Chauhan v. Union of India (2014) and Navneet Kaur v. State (NCT of Delhi) (2014), a Constitution Bench ruled that prolonged, unexplained delay by the Executive in deciding mercy petitions causes agonizing mental torture, violating the right to life under Article 21. 2. No Terrorist Exemption: The Supreme Court in Shatrughan Chauhan explicitly rejected the argument that prisoners convicted of terrorism are excluded from the protection against inordinate delay. Prolonged delay constitutes a supervening circumstance irrespective of the nature of the crime. 3. Conclusion: An unexplained delay of 9 years is shocking and violates Article 21. The death sentence will be commuted by the Supreme Court to life imprisonment.

Distinctions

  • Promulgated by the Executive when the Legislature is in recess.
  • Passed by elected Houses of Legislature following debate and voting.
  • Temporary duration; ceases 6 weeks after legislative reassembly.
  • Permanent duration until amended or repealed by the Legislature.
  • Re-promulgation without legislative tabling is a fraud on the Constitution (Krishna Kumar Singh).
  • Can be re-enacted or renewed indefinitely through legislative majorities.
  • Ordinance Power (Arts 123/213)
  • Regular Legislative Act
  • Completely wipes out both the conviction and the sentence; restores innocent legal status.
  • Does not wipe out the conviction; only mitigates or shortens the punishment.
  • Removes all civil disqualifications resulting from conviction.
  • Conviction remains intact; only custody or severity of sentence is altered.
  • Pardon (Article 72/161)
  • Remission / Commutation

Common misconceptions

The President exercises the pardoning power under Article 72 according to his personal moral conscience and judicial evaluation.

Under Maru Ram v. Union of India (1980), the President and Governor are constitutional heads bound to act strictly on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers under Articles 74 and 163. Personal discretion has no place in the exercise of Article 72.

Ordinance-making power is a parallel, independent legislative power that the government can use as an alternative to Parliament whenever it faces political opposition.

An Ordinance is an exceptional emergency power to deal with unforeseen situations during recess. As held in D.C. Wadhwa and Krishna Kumar Singh, using ordinances to bypass parliamentary debate is a fraud on the Constitution and will be struck down.

Leading cases

  • D.C. Wadhwa v. State of Bihar (1987), (1987) 1 SCC 378 — Mechanical re-promulgation of ordinances without placing them before the legislature is a subversion of the democratic legislative process and a fraud on the Constitution.
  • Krishna Kumar Singh v. State of Bihar (2017), (2017) 3 SCC 1 — 7-judge Bench held that laying ordinances before the legislature is a mandatory constitutional duty; executive satisfaction is subject to judicial review.
  • Maru Ram v. Union of India (1980), (1980) 2 SCC 107 — The pardoning power under Articles 72 and 161 is exercised by the President/Governor strictly on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers, not in personal discretion.
  • Kehar Singh v. Union of India (1989), (1989) 1 SCC 204 — President can re-examine evidence on merits in a mercy petition; convict has no right to oral hearing; judicial review is limited to checking arbitrary exercise of power.
  • Epuru Sudhakar v. Govt. of A.P. (2006), (2006) 8 SCC 161 — Pardoning orders under Articles 72 and 161 are subject to judicial review on grounds of mala fides, extraneous considerations, non-application of mind, or political/caste bias.
  • Shatrughan Chauhan v. Union of India (2014), (2014) 3 SCC 1 — Inordinate, unexplained executive delay in disposing of a death row convict's mercy petition violates Article 21 and justifies automatic commutation of death sentence to life.

Questions & answers

Examine the nature and scope of the Governor's ordinance-making power under Article 213 of the Constitution. Discuss why the Supreme Court declared mechanical re-promulgation of ordinances a fraud on the Constitution in D.C. Wadhwa and Krishna Kumar Singh.

### 1. Synopsis / Introduction

Article 213 of the Constitution confers extraordinary legislative power upon the Governor to promulgate Ordinances during the recess of the State Legislature to meet urgent, unforeseen exigencies. However, this power cannot be transformed into an enduring, parallel mode of executive law-making.

---

### 2. Constitutional Prerequisites under Article 213

1. **Recess of Legislature:** Both Houses (or the single House) of the State Legislature must not be in session.

2. **Immediate Action:** The Governor must be satisfied that circumstances exist requiring immediate legislative intervention.

3. **Legislative Competence:** An Ordinance cannot encroach on subjects outside the State List (List II) or Concurrent List (List III), and cannot abridge Fundamental Rights under Part III.

4. **Parliamentary Expiry:** An Ordinance must be laid before the State Legislature upon reassembly and **ceases to operate six weeks after reassembly**, or earlier if disapproved.

---

### 3. Re-Promulgation as a Fraud on Power: *D.C. Wadhwa* (1987)

In *D.C. Wadhwa v. State of Bihar*, the Supreme Court unearthed an egregious practice where the Bihar government promulgated 256 Ordinances between 1967 and 1981, mechanically re-promulgating them for over a decade without tabling them before the Assembly.

- Chief Justice Bhagwati ruled that mechanical re-promulgation is a **subversion of the democratic legislative process and a brazen fraud on the Constitution**. The executive cannot arrogate to itself the legislative functions of an elected Assembly.

---

### 4. The 7-Judge Benchmark: *Krishna Kumar Singh v. State of Bihar* (2017)

A 7-judge Constitution Bench held:

- **Mandatory Duty to Lay:** Laying an ordinance before the legislature is a mandatory constitutional duty; failure to lay is an abuse of power.

- **Judicial Review of Satisfaction:** The subjective satisfaction of the executive is **subject to judicial review** to ascertain whether objective material existed or whether the power was exercised for extraneous motives.

- **Repeated Re-promulgation Void:** Re-promulgating ordinances without legislative sanction is an unconstitutional nullity.

---

### 5. Conclusion

Ordinances are temporary constitutional life-support mechanisms, not permanent legislative surrogates. *Krishna Kumar Singh* restored legislative primacy, ensuring that laws governing the citizenry derive their legitimacy from public parliamentary debate.

"The sovereign power of clemency under Articles 72 and 161 is a constitutional trust to be exercised strictly on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers, subject to the rule of law and judicial review." Critically examine the nature, scope, and constitutional limitations of the Pardoning Power of the President and Governors. Discuss the landmark jurisprudence in Maru Ram, Kehar Singh, Epuru Sudhakar, and the impact of inordinate delay in Shatrughan Chauhan.

### 1. Introduction: The Prerogative of Mercy in a Constitutional Republic

In historical monarchies, the power of pardon was the personal prerogative of the King as the fountainhead of justice. In the democratic constitutional republic of India, this sovereign power is codified in **Article 72** (for the President of India) and **Article 161** (for Governors of States).

As observed by the US Supreme Court in *Biddle v. Perovich* (1927) and adopted by the Indian Supreme Court, a pardon is not a private act of grace; it is a part of the constitutional scheme, administered to correct possible judicial errors, prevent grave injustice, or advance public welfare.

---

### 2. Forms and Comparative Scope of the Clemency Power

#### The Five Statutory Forms:

1. **Pardon:** Completely blots out the guilt and conviction of the offender, restoring him to the position of an innocent citizen.

2. **Commutation:** Substitutes a heavier sentence with a lighter punishment (e.g., death penalty to rigorous life imprisonment).

3. **Remission:** Reduces the duration of the sentence without altering its legal nature (e.g., reducing 14 years to 10 years).

4. **Respite:** Awards a lesser punishment on special humane grounds (e.g., pregnancy of an inmate).

5. **Reprieve:** Temporarily stays the execution of a sentence to afford time to seek clemency.

#### Comparative Dimensions: Article 72 vs Article 161

- **Substantive Field:** President exercises power regarding Union laws (List I); Governor regarding State laws (List II).

- **Courts-Martial:** Article 72(1)(a) confers exclusive power on the President over sentences passed by military courts-martial. The Governor has no court-martial jurisdiction.

- **Death Sentences:** Under Article 72(1)(c), the President has plenary power over all death sentences. In *State of Haryana v. Raj Kumar @ Titto* (2021) 9 SCC 292, the Supreme Court clarified that the Governor under Article 161 can also remit or commute death sentences, overriding statutory bars under Section 433A CrPC.

---

### 3. The Constitutional Anchor: Aid and Advice of the Council of Ministers

A foundational misconception was that the President or Governor exercises mercy in their personal moral discretion:

- In *Maru Ram v. Union of India* (1980) 2 SCC 107, a 5-judge Constitution Bench settled that **the President and Governors are constitutional heads bound strictly by the aid and advice of their respective Council of Ministers** (Articles 74 and 163).

- Justice V.R. Krishna Iyer ruled:

> *"The President does not act on his own personal lights, but must act on the advice of the Council of Ministers... The power under Article 72 is the power of the Central Government, and the power under Article 161 is the power of the State Government."*

---

### 4. Judicial Review of Pardoning Power: The Jurisprudential Trajectory

#### A. Nature of the Power: *Kehar Singh v. Union of India* (1989) 1 SCC 204

In the mercy petition of Kehar Singh (convicted of the assassination of Prime Minister Indira Gandhi):

1. **Merits Re-examination:** The Supreme Court held that the President can scrutinize the evidence and come to a different conclusion from that of the judicial courts.

2. **No Oral Hearing:** The convict has no constitutional right to be heard orally by the President.

3. **Limited Review:** The court will not evaluate the adequacy of reasons, but retains jurisdiction to prevent arbitrary or corrupt exercise of power.

#### B. The Landmark on Grounds of Review: *Epuru Sudhakar v. Govt. of A.P.* (2006) 8 SCC 161

The Governor of Andhra Pradesh granted a full remission to a Congress activist convicted of murdering two political rivals. Striking down the remission, the Supreme Court laid down that pardoning orders are subject to judicial review on four clear grounds:

1. **Non-application of mind;**

2. **Mala fides / Malice in law;**

3. **Reliance on extraneous or wholly irrelevant considerations;**

4. **Arbitrariness, political favoritism, or caste and religious bias.**

Justice Kapadia famously emphasized that the rule of law is the supreme value: *"Pardon cannot be an instrument of political cronyism or executive lawlessness."*

---

### 5. Inordinate Delay and Article 21: *Shatrughan Chauhan v. Union of India* (2014) 3 SCC 1

Can the Executive keep a death row convict's mercy petition pending indefinitely?

- In *Shatrughan Chauhan*, a 3-judge Bench held that **unexplained and unreasonable executive delay** in deciding mercy petitions causes immense psychological torture, violating the fundamental right to life and dignity under **Article 21**.

- **Automatic Commutation:** The Court ruled that inordinate delay constitutes a supervening circumstance justifying the **commutation of the death penalty to life imprisonment**.

- **No Terrorist Exception:** The Court firmly rejected the Union's argument that terror convicts are excluded from the protection against executive delay (*Navneet Kaur*, 2014).

---

### 6. Summary Matrix: The Clemency Architecture

| Aspect | Constitutional Principle | Landmark Authority |

| :--- | :--- | :--- |

| **Decision-Making Agency** | Council of Ministers (Aid & Advice) | *Maru Ram v. Union of India* (1980) |

| **Oral Hearing** | No fundamental right to oral hearing | *Kehar Singh v. Union of India* (1989) |

| **Judicial Review Scope** | Reviewable for mala fides, extraneous grounds, bias | *Epuru Sudhakar v. Govt. of A.P.* (2006) |

| **Executive Delay** | Inordinate delay commutes death to life under Art 21 | *Shatrughan Chauhan v. Union of India* (2014) |

| **Governor Death Mercy** | Governor has power under Art 161 over death row | *State of Haryana v. Raj Kumar* (2021) |

---

### 7. Conclusion

Articles 72 and 161 represent the humane apex of the Indian legal pyramid. By subordinating the exercise of clemency to ministerial advice, the rule of law (*Epuru Sudhakar*), and the compassionate mandates of Article 21 (*Shatrughan Chauhan*), the Supreme Court has ensured that constitutional mercy remains a dignified instrument of justice rather than an arbitrary royal prerogative.

Bare Act pointers

  • Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 — sections 104–106, 109 and 63 where applicable
  • Art 72 — Presidential pardoning power (Union laws, court martial, death)
  • Art 123 — Presidential ordinance-making power during recess of Parliament
  • Art 161 — Governor's pardoning power (State laws)
  • Art 213 — Governor's ordinance-making power during recess of State Legislature

Judgments on this provision