Kehar Singh v. Union of India (1988)

Supreme Court of India · (1989) 1 SCC 204 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench

Summary

Authoritative 5-judge Constitution Bench precedent on the President’s pardon power under Article 72 in capital cases. Held that in exercising power under Article 72, the President can scrutinize the evidence on record afresh and come to a different conclusion from the court. However, the convict has no constitutional right to insist on an oral hearing before the President.

Facts

  • Kehar Singh was convicted of criminal conspiracy under Section 120B read with Section 302 IPC in the assassination of Prime Minister Indira Gandhi and sentenced to death.
  • His conviction and sentence were confirmed by the High Court and the Supreme Court dismissed his appeal and review petition.
  • His son submitted a clemency petition to the President of India under Article 72, requesting an oral hearing and presenting arguments that evidence had been misappreciated by the courts.
  • The President rejected the petition with a communication stating that the President cannot go into the merits of a case finally decided by the highest court of the land.
  • Kehar Singh filed a writ petition under Article 32 contending that the President had declined to exercise constitutional jurisdiction under a misconception of law.

Issues

  • What is the nature and scope of the President power under Article 72 of the Constitution.
  • Whether the President has the power to examine the evidentiary record afresh and differ from the judicial verdict.
  • Whether a condemned prisoner is entitled to an oral hearing before the President decides a clemency petition.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Presidential power to scrutinize evidence afresh

Pathak, C.J. held that the power under Article 72 is of the widest amplitude. It is entirely separate from the judicial power. In exercising power under Article 72, the President does not amend or alter the judicial record; the judicial verdict remains intact. However, the President can examine the evidence afresh and come to a different conclusion regarding the guilt or appropriateness of the sentence.

No right to oral hearing in clemency petitions

The Court held that there is no fundamental or natural justice right to an oral hearing before the President. The manner in which the clemency petition is disposed of is within the discretion of the President; written representations are entirely sufficient.

Decision

Writ petition disposed of. The Supreme Court held that the President had misconstrued the scope of Article 72 in assuming he could not look into the merits, and directed that the clemency petition be reconsidered on its merits (which was subsequently reconsidered and rejected).

Ratio decidendi

The power of the President under Article 72 is an executive constitutional power distinct from judicial adjudication. The President is entitled to scrutinize the evidence on record and determine whether the sentence should be executed, commuted, or pardoned. However, the convict has no legal or constitutional right to demand an oral hearing before the President.

Exam points

  • Settled that the President under Article 72 can look into the merits of the case and differ from the court.
  • Ruled that there is NO right to an oral hearing before the President under Article 72.
  • Clarified that the judicial verdict remains intact; clemency is an executive act of mercy.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Article 72, Pardon, Death Penalty, Clemency, Indira Gandhi Assassination

All judgments