Krishna Kumar Singh v. State of Bihar (2017)
Supreme Court of India · (2017) 3 SCC 1 · 7-Judge Constitution Bench
Summary
Landmark 7-judge Constitution Bench decision comprehensively reviewing the ordinance-making power under Articles 123 and 213. Held that the requirement of placing an ordinance before the legislature is mandatory. Successive re-promulgation of ordinances without legislative approval is an unconstitutional fraud on the Constitution. Rights created under an ordinance that has ceased to operate do not survive unless protected under an enduring character test.
Facts
- The State of Bihar promulgated the Bihar Non-Government Sanskrit Schools (Taking Over of Management and Control) Ordinance in 1989 to take over 429 private Sanskrit schools.
- Over the next three years, the State Government repeatedly re-promulgated the ordinance seven times without ever tabling it before the Bihar State Legislature.
- Eventually, the eighth ordinance lapsed in 1992, and the State Government refused to pay salaries to the teachers, claiming that the taking over had lapsed.
- The teachers filed writ petitions claiming that once the schools were taken over by an ordinance, the transfer created permanent rights that survived the lapsing of the ordinance.
- A 7-judge Constitution Bench was constituted to determine the constitutional limits of ordinance promulgation and the effect of lapsed ordinances.
Issues
- Whether the constitutional requirement of laying an ordinance before the legislature under Article 213(2)(a) is mandatory or directory.
- Whether the mechanical re-promulgation of ordinances is unconstitutional and a fraud on the Constitution.
- Whether rights, privileges, or liabilities created under an ordinance survive after the ordinance ceases to operate.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Mandatory nature of laying ordinances before legislature
Chandrachud, J. for the majority held that placing an ordinance before the legislature is a mandatory constitutional duty. The failure to lay an ordinance before the legislature constitutes a serious constitutional infraction, defeating legislative oversight. Re-promulgation of ordinances without legislative approval is an impermissible usurpation of legislative power and a fraud on the Constitution.
The test of enduring rights under a lapsed ordinance
An ordinance is by nature temporary and conditional. Rights created under an ordinance do not automatically survive its expiration. Whether an act done under an expired ordinance survives depends on whether the effects are irreversible, whether reversing them is impractical, and whether public interest requires their preservation (the enduring character test).
Decision
Appeals dismissed. Re-promulgation held unconstitutional. The taking over of Sanskrit schools did not survive the lapsing of the ordinance, though unpaid salaries for the period of actual service were directed to be settled.
Ratio decidendi
The requirement of placing an ordinance before the elected legislature is mandatory. The ordinance-making power under Article 123 and 213 cannot be utilized to subvert the legislative process. Repeated re-promulgation without legislative enactment is a subversion of the democratic process and a fraud on constitutional power. Rights created under an ordinance do not automatically survive its lapse.
Exam points
- 7-judge Constitution Bench ruling expanding on D.C. Wadhwa.
- Settled that laying an ordinance before the legislature is mandatory, not directory.
- Formulated the "enduring character test" for rights created under lapsed ordinances.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Article 213, Article 123, Ordinance, Separation of Powers