Epuru Sudhakar v. Govt. of Andhra Pradesh (2006)

Supreme Court of India · (2006) 8 SCC 161 · 2-Judge Bench

Summary

Landmark Supreme Court precedent subjecting the clemency and pardon powers of the President under Article 72 and the Governor under Article 161 to judicial review. Held that clemency cannot be granted on political, communal, or whimsical grounds; if the exercise of pardon power is tainted by mala fides, extraneous considerations, or non-application of mind, constitutional courts will strike down the order.

Facts

  • Gowru Venkata Reddy, a political activist belonging to the ruling Congress party in Andhra Pradesh, was convicted under Section 302 IPC for the murder of a Telugu Desam Party (TDP) leader and his son, and sentenced to life imprisonment.
  • After the change of government in the State, his wife (who was a Member of the Legislative Assembly) submitted a petition for clemency to the Governor.
  • The Governor of Andhra Pradesh invoked Article 161 and granted remission of the unexpired sentence of over 7 years.
  • The son of the deceased victim filed a writ petition challenging the remission order as an abuse of power motivated entirely by political favoritism.
  • The High Court dismissed the petition, and the son appealed to the Supreme Court.

Issues

  • Whether the pardoning and remission power of the Governor under Article 161 (and President under Article 72) is amenable to judicial review.
  • What are the permissible legal grounds on which a constitutional court can review and quash a clemency order.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Pardon is subject to limited judicial review

Pasayat, J. held that the power under Articles 72 and 161 is a constitutional responsibility and not a personal favor. It is well settled that judicial review of the order of pardon or remission is available on specific grounds: (a) that the order has been passed without application of mind; (b) that the order is mala fide; (c) that the order has been passed on extraneous or wholly irrelevant considerations; (d) that relevant materials were kept out of consideration; or (e) that the order suffers from arbitrariness.

Rule of law prevents political pardons

Kapadia, J. in his concurring opinion emphasized that the Rule of Law is the basis of all constitutional provisions. If pardon power is exercised on political or communal considerations, it strikes at the foundation of the administration of justice. In the present case, relevant facts concerning 8 other criminal cases pending against the convict were concealed from the Governor.

Decision

Appeal allowed. The remission order passed by the Governor under Article 161 was quashed and set aside for non-application of mind and consideration of extraneous political factors.

Ratio decidendi

The power of the President under Article 72 and the Governor under Article 161 is a constitutional power that must be exercised in accordance with public interest and the rule of law. It is open to judicial review on established grounds including mala fides, extraneous or irrelevant considerations, non-application of mind, or keeping relevant facts out of consideration. A pardon granted on political grounds violates Article 14.

Exam points

  • Settled the 5 grounds of judicial review over Presidential and Gubernatorial pardons.
  • Quashed a Governor clemency order granted on political party favoritism.
  • Reinforced the supremacy of the Rule of Law over executive clemency under Articles 72 and 161.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Article 161, Article 72, Pardon, Judicial Review, Mala Fides

All judgments