Dr. D.C. Wadhwa v. State of Bihar (1987)
Supreme Court of India · (1987) 1 SCC 378 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench
Summary
Constitution Bench precedent holding that the mechanical, successive re-promulgation of ordinances by the Governor without placing them before the state legislature is a subversion of the democratic legislative process and a colorable fraud on the Constitution under Article 213.
Facts
- Dr. D.C. Wadhwa, a professor of economics at the Gokhale Institute of Politics and Economics, conducted extensive empirical research revealing that the State of Bihar had governed via "Ordinance Raj".
- Between 1967 and 1981, the Governor of Bihar promulgated 256 ordinances which were kept alive for years through successive mechanical re-promulgations without ever being placed before or enacted by the Bihar State Legislature.
- Some ordinances were kept alive indefinitely for up to 14 years without legislative scrutiny.
- Dr. Wadhwa filed a public interest writ petition under Article 32 challenging the constitutional validity of this practice.
Issues
- Whether the petitioner had locus standi to challenge the practice of mechanical re-promulgation of ordinances.
- Whether the Governor has the constitutional power under Article 213 to repeatedly re-promulgate ordinances without introducing bills before the legislature, thereby bypassing democratic scrutiny.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Emergency nature of ordinance-making power
Bhagwati, C.J. held that the executive power to promulgate ordinances under Article 213 (and Article 123 for the President) is an extraordinary power conceived to deal with urgent situations when the legislature is not in session. It cannot be converted into an ordinary power of legislation or used to bypass the elected legislature.
Colorable legislation and fraud on the Constitution
Article 213(2) mandates that an ordinance must be laid before the legislative assembly and shall cease to operate after six weeks from reassembly. Mechanical re-promulgation without placing the ordinance before the legislature constitutes a colorable exercise of power and a fraud on the Constitution, subverting parliamentary democracy.
Decision
Writ petition allowed. The Supreme Court held that the petitioner as a citizen had locus standi to challenge widespread constitutional subversion. Successive re-promulgation of ordinances without legislative enactment is a fraud on the Constitution and renders the re-promulgated ordinances void.
Ratio decidendi
The executive power to promulgate ordinances under Article 213 is an emergency power conceived to deal with urgent situations when the legislature is not in session. It cannot be converted into an ordinary power of legislation. Mechanical re-promulgation without placing the ordinance before the legislature violates the constitutional mandate and constitutes a colorable exercise of power and a fraud on the Constitution.
Exam points
- Establishes the anti-ordinance raj doctrine under Article 213 and Article 123.
- Defines colorable exercise of power and fraud on the Constitution in administrative/legislative law.
- Affirmed locus standi of citizens and academics to vindicate the rule of law via PIL.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Article 213, Ordinance, Colorable Legislation, Separation of Powers